New Articles

Best Practices in Global Trade with Thomas A. Cook: Managing Landed Costs in the Global Supply Chain

Managing Landed Costs in the Global Supply Chain logistics

Best Practices in Global Trade with Thomas A. Cook: Managing Landed Costs in the Global Supply Chain

Personnel managing their global supply chains according to recognized best practices will manage their total costs of good purchased or sold through modeling the “landed costs.”

Landed cost is the total cost of a product once it has arrived at the buyer’s door. What follows are the components that are needed to determine landed costs, including the original price of the item (converted to U.S. dollars, all custom brokerage and handling charges, complete freight and shipping costs, custom duties, tariffs, taxes, insurance, packaging costs and surcharges.

  • Purchase price of goods (acquisition cost) – variable depending on unit price and quantity (converted to USD)
  • Buying agents fees – variable depending on level of service
  • Consolidation – securing LCL shipments into larger shipments and coordinating freight from several suppliers
  • Local trucking and international freight – variable, depending upon choice of mode, carrier, freight rate negotiation and surcharges
  • Duty – variable percentage of the value Customs put on your goods … typically origin and HTS# factored
  • Tax (goods and services tax or value added tax) – $ variable percentage of (The Customs value of cost of goods + freight + insurance + Customs duty)
  • Insurance charges, typically referred to as cargo insurance
  • Customs clearance, ISF, CBP 7501, courier and handling charges, etc.
  • Storage and deconsolidation
  • Inland freight– from inbound gateway to final destination
  • Demurrage – if applicable when potential delays occur. (Note: this became a more impactful expense and concern through the pandemic.)

Every supply chain will have some unique factors and variables that impact landed costs that must be taken into consideration. However, the above generic model will serve as a base template for landed cost calculations.

I firmly believe that senior management and a “best-practice mindset” warrants paying attention to this critical detail in global trade and supply chain management.

In an international trade, both parties enter into a purchase agreement that will include either named or by default an “INCO Term,” as defined by the International Chamber of Commerce in Paris, subscribed to by most trading nations of the world that belong to the United Nations.

As an example: Importers into the United States by ocean freight typically buy FOB outbound gateway. In China this might be written as FOB Shanghai.

This means that the buyer will assume all risks and costs once the goods are placed onboard the ocean-going vessel in the port of export from overseas. The key words being “risks and costs.”

A potential additional cost in the import or export transaction will be the cost of marine cargo insurance and typically would be considered a necessary component of reducing the risks involved in international transportation.

Marine insurance, when thoroughly written, offers “All Risk,” “Warehouse to Warehouse” coverage for the buyer at specific terms and a rate of premium to be agreed.

Exporters also need to be concerned with landed costs:

  • They need to make sure that the final costs to their customers are competitively structured, which would mean the accumulation of costs to get from the origin to destination, and everything included.
  • The choice of INCO Term may require them to bear all the logistics and customs charges such as in a DDP (delivered duty paid) transaction.
  • Areas such as quality customer service, profitability, margin impact.
  • The exporters freight costs may be less expensive than what the importer would pay.
  • To accommodate foreign customer needs.
  • In e-commerce transactions, the INCO Term DDP is a very likely option in an export sale, which the shipper (exporter) would cover in the COGS.  Thus, obtaining competitive freight costs (international and last mile) will help reduce the overall landed cost.

The following recommendations should be considered: 

  • Learn how INCO Terms impact cost and risk in every transaction and learn to leverage the best INCO Term between you and your supplier and/or buyer.
  • Review all areas of cost in the landed cost model to determine where savings might exist. It might be negotiating better freight rates, or service provider fees.

For example, it might be from sourcing from a country that we have a free trade agreement with, thereby eliminating the duty and tariff.

Companies that import from China are greatly impacted by the 301 tariffs, which added as much as 25% additional cost due to the duty surcharge, which was implemented during the Trump Administration and continued with President Biden’s policies.

By considering another country as a manufacturing source could greatly impact the calculation of duty and tax.

Near-shoring and friend-shoring have grown over the past six years and will likely continue to expand as the risks tied into costs on goods originating in China have created significant exposure to sustainable supply chain management.

Another area would be the HTS number utilized, impacting duties and tax rates.  Keep in mind that it is the country of origin and the product HTS number outlined in a matrix within customs regulations that determine the duty rates.

Mode of transportation will impact landed costs. Many times, air freight is utilized, when ocean freight could be a less expensive option. This means better demand planning and coordination between purchasing/sales/sourcing and the logistics department handling the transportation choices.

Included in this area is control over the suppliers with setting more realistic expectations, tighter control over order status and communications, contractual obligations, and penalties for non-performance.

  • Inland freight expenses can be included in the ocean freight, where there is an opportunity to leverage the larger ocean freight spend to obtain a better inland freight cost.
  • Utilization of technology and reducing “paper” in the transaction can reduce ISF, Customs clearance and handling charges when automation replaces repetitive human handling of import and export documentation.
  • When freight does not have to be consolidated or deconsolidated and can be shipped in units direct from suppler to point of end use, will also reduce costs.

The pandemic took witness to unprecedented increase in freight pricing all over the world. Through 2022, we saw a normalization of freight pricing take hold.

In 2023, the pricing is moving toward pre-pandemic levels and there are signs that demand is diminishing, which might impact pricing to even more competitive levels.

For companies with larger volumes, negotiating certain incidental costs in a soft freight market is available. Surcharges such as PSS, GRI’s and BAF will also impact landed costs favorably.

  • Another option is to minimize the number of service providers and carriers where you can better leverage your freight spend.
  • Freight forwarders, customhouse brokers, 3PLs and other forms of service providers when chosen wisely can be a very critical partner in your global supply chain to both assist in reducing risk and spend through their resources, knowledge, and skill sets.
  • The pandemic forced supply chain managers to pay attention to detail to a much greater extent. This scrutiny brought magnification of all the components of an international transaction.
  • Make sure the risk of loss and damage during transit is managed with a marine cargo insurance policy, written through a qualified insurance broker and underwriting company. And guarantee the terms are customized to the unique risks associated with your supply chain model.
  • In purchasing, when we strive to negotiate a competitive price, we should be wary of “cheap pricing,” as the “cheapest” may have trade-offs on timeliness, safety, and security.

To improve the landed cost model, you must first identify the areas of cost and which ones can be impacted favorably. This will work best in a collaborative process internally with all your stakeholders and externally with all your service providers and consultants.

The assessment process should lead to strategies followed by tactics that develop into action steps creating favorable results in reducing “landed costs” in your global supply chain.

Thomas A. Cook is a seasoned global supply chain professional, author of more than 20 books on global trade and managing director of Blue Tiger International. He can be reached at tomcook@bluetigerintl.com or (516) 359-6232. 

insert

The Four Big Challenges of Exporting Successfully: Explained and Answered

While there are numerous challenges that companies in all business verticals face, there are four that dominate the export process. Manage these successfully and you’ll reduce export headaches and maximize the profitability and long-term sustainability of your export program.

The four areas are:

1. Choice of INCO Terms
2. Logistics
3. Import Clearance
4. Getting Paid

1. Choice of INCO Terms

INCO Terms are internationally recognized terms of sale between exporters and importers that go back over 65 years, managed by the International Chamber of Commerce in Paris, France.

Incoterms provide a universal set of rules and guidelines that help facilitate trade. In essence, they provide a common language that traders use to set the terms of their trades. Buyers and sellers can use Incoterms in a variety of activities necessary to conduct business. Typical activities that call for the use of Incoterms include filling out a purchase order, labeling a shipment for transport, completing a certificate of origin, or documenting an import or export transaction.

There are 11 INCO Term options:

Incoterms Applying to Any Mode of Transport

The following Incoterm rules apply to any mode of transport:

  •  EXW – Ex Works (insert place of delivery)
  •  CIP – Carriage and Insurance Paid To (insert place of destination)
  •  CPT – Carriage Paid to (insert place of destination)
  •  DAP – Delivered at Place (insert named place of destination)
  •  DPU – Delivered at Place Unloaded (insert place of destination)
  •  DDP – Delivered Duty Paid (insert place of destination)
  •  FCA – Free Carrier (Insert named place of delivery)

Incoterms Applying to Sea and Inland Waterway Transport

The following Incoterm rules apply to sea and inland waterway transport:

  • CFR – Cost and Freight (insert named port of destination)
  • CIF – Cost Insurance and Freight (insert named port of destination)
  • FAS – Free Alongside Ship (insert name of port of loading)
  • FOB – Free on Board (insert named port of loading)

It is important for exporters to learn all the options and in collaboration with their foreign buyer choose the best term that mirrors the intended transaction.

CAUTION: For exporters we do not recommend Ex Works or Delivered Duty Paid Inco Term options. We prefer FAS or any of the “Cxx” terms where better control can be maintained.

NOTE: E-commerce export sales usually require the use of the DDP Term, again for greater control.

2. Logistics

Exporting requires moving freight from origin to destination, crossing international borders, often over greater distances, and at times subject to potentially harsh and dangerous exposures.

We make the following recommendations in handling export logistics:

– Make sure that your personnel who will be handling this responsibility are well-trained. NIWT.org is a viable option for export training. Better informed staff will produce better outcomes.

– Make sure the packaging of your shipment will meet the demands of the journey.

– Establish a good working relationship with a capable and experienced freight forwarder. Their knowledge will be a great asset to your export supply chain performance.

– Since the beginning of the pandemic, logistics has become more expensive with greater delays. Allow sufficient time to meet customer delivery requirements and budget higher costs for transportation.

– Track and trace your shipments. Due diligence will assure that the goods arrive at the intended destination timely and responsibly.

– Pay attention to export trade compliance. Make sure you are checking the denied parties list, follow all export regulations and apply due diligence and reasonable care along with supervision and control in your export program.

The fines and penalties for non-compliance can be severe.

3. Import Clearance

Always keep in mind that the goods that you are selling will need to go through customs formalities in the country of destination.

This will mean:

– Adherence to the import regulations of the country you are selling to

– That includes packing, marking, labeling and documentation requirements

– Correct Harmonized Tariff Schedule Numbers

– Import permits and potentially other documentary requirements.

The use of a qualified freight forwarder together with collaboration with the buyer and informed personnel will all mitigate this challenge.

4. Getting Paid

If you do all three of the prior steps correctly yet do not get paid, it will all be for naught.

Getting your money paid upfront before shipping is always a good option but is likely not to be competitive. Offering terms is typically a better long-term strategy.

Due diligence to consider, when offering terms:

– Judiciously vet the companies you sell to

– Letters of credit can work, but are costly

– Payment drafts against documents can work but pose some risk

– Arranging for export credit risk can be a viable option, which comes at lower cost and can offer risk avoidance. At Blue Tiger International, we have a program available to companies that services exporters requiring receivable protection.

Summary

Exporting creates opportunity for all industries but also creates risk. Manage the risks through these four pillars of exporting and you will significantly reduce exposure, maximize profits, and create a robust long-term export program.

The Author

Thomas A. Cook Is a 30-year seasoned veteran of global trade and Managing Director of Blue Tiger International, based in New York, LA and West Palm Beach, Florida.

The author of 19 books on international business, two best business sellers. Graduate of NYS Maritime Academy with an undergraduate and graduate degree in marine transportation and business management.

Tom has a worldwide presence through over 300 agents in every major city along with an array of transportation providers and solutions.

Tom works with a number of Associations providing “value add” to their membership services and enhancing their overall reach into global sourcing and in export sales management.

konecranes xchange model

Global Supply Chain Management: “A Look Back, A Look Ahead”

Strategies for Managing the Impact of Freight Disruption

The last two years have created significant challenges for global supply chains.  As we enter into 2022 we need to reflect on the last 22 months to better prepare for 2022 and beyond.

The impact to the automotive aftermarket has been unprecedented and significant, fraught with increasing issues in meeting customer and industry demands.

The issues we faced can be summed up as follows: delays, costs, and uncertainty.

As the pandemic grew in February 2020 to year end 2021, every month the problem grew worse in the form of delays, increased costs, and difficulties in demand planning as a result of the continued uncertainties in global markets and the transportation infrastructure moving freight globally.

While every business vertical and country in the world saw disruption, manufacturers and distributors in the automotive aftermarket, with huge dependencies on Asian markets and in just-in-time parts distribution, saw dramatic increases in freight costs and long delays.

The primary cause of the disruption relates to two areas: increases in demand and limitations in capacity.

The demand – starting with consumers, then followed by industry and government agencies, all on a buying spree and seeking enhanced inventory balances – has never been seen in modern history.

This demand has impacted manufacturing, production, demand planning and distribution management.

This historical increase in demand has overwhelmed the global transportation infrastructure that enables comprehensive and timely performance.

The results are frustration, anger, dismay, and even belligerence toward all companies associated with logistics services: Carriers, Freight Forwarders, NVOCC’s/Consolidators, Customhouse Brokers, 3PL’s and related companies.

The problems are huge, complex, and multi-caused.

They derive from the demand vs capacity issues, but when viewed on a micro-level they are caused by a shortage of drivers, trucks, chassis, manpower, handling and shipping equipment, space limitations, Covid-caused blackouts, shortfalls in demand planning, closed facilities, mis-routings, Covid shut-downs, greed, ill-preparedness, weather and a host of other issues.

That multitude of issues is where the challenges derive from, have now existed for two years, continue to worsen, and show no real end in the short-term.

Demand planning for buyers meeting manufacturing, distribution and customer needs is very much in disarray as the uncertainty of the Covid pandemic has made this responsibility a very difficult one to manage successfully and consistently.

There are two big questions we must consider when preparing for the challenges coming at us in 2022: When will it end?   And what can we do about the issues associated with the pandemic disruption?

When will it end?

We utilize both quantitative and qualitative data obtained from numerous government and confidential data banks and resources. We compile and analyze the data, combined with our own insight and experience gained over the last 40 years of operating in global supply chains, to draw conclusions and make recommendations.

Our best guess places the disruption to begin to subside in the third quarter of 2022 and last through Chinese New Year 2023.

A Look Ahead:  Predictions

From observing delays and pricing as we enter 2022 and look ahead, here are some of our predictions:

  • Delays will continue to increase in ocean freight through to the Fall of 2022
  • Air, truck, and rail will still have some capacity issues, which will more quickly subside, by the summer of 2022
  • Warehouse space will continue to have capacity limitations and price increases as much as 20%
  • Principal manufacturers and distributors will upgrade the role of supply chain management in their business models and seek options that produce lower risk, and possibly accepting cost increases as reasonable trade-offs for on-time performance, dependability and “ride, as-booked” options.
  • The most problematic trade lane has been between USA and China, particularly on imports to the Americas.
  • This factor combined with China/USA political and economic instability, IPR concerns, trade imbalances, forced labor issues and increased costs … will cause numerous companies to seek sources for alternative manufacturing and moving to new suppliers in other more friendly countries, near shoring back to the USA or Mexico … but certainly out of China.
  • Companies will aggressively seek other opportunities to reduce risk and spend. These might be utilization of programs in drawback, foreign trade zones, bonded warehousing, free trade agreements, tariff engineering … to name a few options.
  • Logistics managers will more closely manage their vendor relationships in providing freight services. Price will be less of a driving factor, more dominated by performance.
  • Demand planning systems will need to become more pliable and flexible in their approach to product ordering.

Procurement teams will work harder to study historical data, combined with future anticipated needs and collaborate more closely with suppliers in better predicting need and the time frames for purchase ordering.

  • Technology will be moving at light speed to make supply chains run better, more cost efficiently and allow for ease of demand planning requirements.

The integration of technology between manufacturers, distributors, service providers, carriers, vendors, government agencies and customers will become more robust, thereby more efficient and cost-effective operational connections between the parties in the supply chain.

We have been involved in numerous supply chain disruptions since the late 1970’s. From Hurricane Katrina in 2005, The Japanese Tsunami in 2011, the Global Financial Crisis of 2008/9, to the events surrounding 9/11 … these are a few of the more recent global crises that have had major disruptive impact to world trade and global supply chains.

We as a country and as a globally connected trading partner managed to get through all of these over time with the right actions. Though this Covid-19 pandemic has been much worse on a global scale, many of the lessons-learned from those preceding events have guided us to potentially successful solutions, tried and tested.

A Look Ahead:  Recommended Actions

Looking ahead, we are outlining six action items for 2022 Global Supply Chain Preparedness:

Companies now recognize the increasing importance of supply chain management, resulting in the following actions and accomplishments:

  • Raising the profile of supply chain senior management to a “seat at the table” in your organization, giving them more authority and influence on decisions impacting the business … leading to less disruption in the supply chain
  • Build resilience in the supply chain, making longer-term decisions that may tradeoff short term cost implications.
  • Successful supply chain management in every business model requires intense collaborative processes among all the silos of any organization.

Senior management must create a culture and pathway for robust collaboration.

In a pandemic, as circumstances disrupt the supply chain,  flexibility, pliability and the ability to demonstrate a willingness to change direction are critical attributes to managing the challenges and creating pathways moving forward.

In this Covid-19 pandemic over the past two years we have closely monitored over one hundred global supply chains, and we can clearly and concisely conclude that those supply chains that bent like a willow tree in the winds of disruption survived and even prospered. Those that were not willing to bend became stuck and were on the losing side of their business models.

Take for example, a Baltimore-based distributor of tire rims who had two primary selling channels, big box retailers and e-commerce.

Before Covid, they imported from two major suppliers, one in China, the other in Spain. They brought all merchandise into a 250,000 sq ft facility on the US East Coast, near their corporate office in Maryland. This model was opened in 1981 and continued through to the Fall of 2020, when it started to fail.

Covid caused huge delays in meeting the big box retailer’s PO requirements on delivery. In e-commerce, where margins were thin, additional inbound freight costs impacted profitability as well as financial viability.

They engaged our firm. We took a four-step process to mitigate their issues:

The process, in a simplified review, studied the details of their business model and how the supply chain operated. We benchmarked that model and began to collaborate on potential solutions.

Once we identified potential solutions, we determined financially and operationally how the potential solutions might impact and work within their business model, with some modifications and process changes.

For the big box retailers, who had their own consolidations going on in China, we changed the delivery from their U.S. warehouses to their consolidation facilities in China.

The big box retailer controlled more volume and ocean freight carrier capacity, and through their allocation allotments were in a much better position to move the freight timelier.  It worked.

With the e-commerce business, we designed the capability to ship directly from a fulfillment center near Shanghai, through a consolidator, and then last mile to the customers in the U.S.  We eliminated the warehousing in the USA, which was a mainly a “pass-through,” i.e., no value-add.  And when shipments were under the $800 de minimis value we also eliminated some of the tariff and customs clearance costs. We not only protected margin but now offered a more competitive “landed cost” model.

Bottom line: in this difficult period of supply chain disruption we were able to impact cost and risk with a supply chain management team that demonstrated flexibility and creativity in their approach to problem resolution.

We are also recommending that monies be budgeted and allocated to more robust integration in the supply chain, from the PO through to shipping, inventory WIP and distribution, which can create efficiencies and more cost-effective operations.

Resource development is part of information gain. And information is “gold” anytime a major disruptive event like Covid-19 occurs. Executives involved in business models with critical supply chain operations must allocate time and money to resources and information gain.

Better decisions come directly from more informed decision-makers.

Even when the transportation infrastructure finally catches up to the demand and costs are lowered, we do not anticipate that a 40’ Container from China into the West Coast of the United States, which cost $2,750 in 2019, and is now costing $23,500 in January 2022, is not likely to go back down to $2,750 but more likely will settle in at around $4,000-6,000 range.

As such, both in the short-term and in the long-term we should anticipate that freight as a component of “Landed Cost” will likely cost us more now and into the future.

Drewry Consultants in the UK are an excellent source for freight information and assessment. From their website a sampling of freight costs:

One of the impacts of the pandemic is personnel working from home, all over the world. To some extent, this has been a resolution strategy, but from another perspective is adding to overall disruption in the global supply chain arena.

In either case, with the uptick in the Covid Omicron surge we currently face globally, it appears that working remotely is likely to continue well into 2022.

The point being as we adapted to this remote business model, we need to accept its continued presence and create better methods to assure personnel productivity, performance and supply chain skill set.

The remote model may have been a “band-aid” solution but most of us in senior management have raised concerns about its effectiveness on areas of employee performance.

If the supply chain disruption challenge continues, which all predictive models point to that occurrence, our remote supply chain, procurement, logistics and management teams must find creative ways, flexible pathways and solutions that work well in that “work-at-home” mode of operation.

Summary

All of us in global supply chain, in all business verticals including the automotive aftermarket, should feel good about how we performed in the past two years among such uncertainty and disruption.

While most supply chains faced difficulties, most found ways to navigate to successful solutions and mitigating options.

As we look forward, many of these challenges will still exist and some even will become more volatile. Many of the comments, recommendations and thoughts produced in the article can be beacons of direction to find both solution and mitigation.

“Article previously published in Aftermarket News Magazine, Feb. 2022,”

 

 

key strategy stock photo

Developing a Post-Pandemic Strategy: The Great Export USA Reset

The pandemic disrupted global supply chains and shattered supply-demand norms, spurring a new appetite for US exports.

USA-based companies in many verticals have a unique opportunity to sell abroad in general and more specifically “post-Covid” where a window of opportunity has opened.

The opportunity has developed as many typical developing nations and even some stalwart supplier nations have had difficulty in manufacturing, distribution, and supply chain management.

The demand for consumer items has shown unprecedented growth all over the world, including Europe, Middle East, larger African nations, and certain countries in Asia.

The typical supplier markets of the world have fallen short in delivering timely, competitively priced, and high-quality products, as they had pre-Covid.

That void has been filled by a few American manufacturers and distributors, but the opportunities can easily be expanded to a much larger group of USA-based companies.

The opportunities are out there … but one needs to know where they are, how best to access and how best to export.

The balance of this article and the additional three parts to this series will explore the challenges and even more importantly … create the blueprint for successful export sales business development.

This first article will outline all the major issues to consider when building a successful export program. These concepts will apply to a company new to export or even a more seasoned exporter.

Exports can create significant opportunity for companies seeking expansion of their overseas markets. Keep in mind that 95% of the consumer market lies external to the United States.

Having said that, exports can create certain risks. It is critical to understanding these risks and managing these exposures so that success can be gained. Tied into the successful exporter are creating “Best Practices” which reduce risk and create the best path forward.

Best Practices Summary:

Make sure you are committed to exporting.
Exporting requires funding, resource development and time. Make sure you have budgeted correctly for export business development and are aligned with external resources to provide support.

Depending upon your internal expertise, utilizing third party consultants who excel in this area, would be a prudent decision.

Assess your product’s export readiness.

You need to determine how ready your product is for the export market. This could include formulizations, packing, marking, labeling, ingredient structure, etc.

Keep in mind, that different countries have different rules, that are critical to know, acknowledge and comply with.

Export Data is essential.

Collecting data on exports provides an initial overview of potential markets and insight on where you should focus. Partnering with consultants accessing information, data and statistics on exports is very important. In the USA, the Department of Commerce can be an invaluable resource.

Short-term focus.

Identify 2-4 initial markets to reach out to. “Experiment”. Test the opportunities and determine the viability of your export opportunities. Begin the learning curve and adapt.

Selling directly or through distributors/agents.

Part of your assessment will be to determine whether to sell direct to end-users or go through importers/agents/distributors.
Generally, we recommend selling through third parties, especially in the beginning.

Advantages:

– Immediate local expertise
– Immediate access to potential clients and sales
– Assumes some of the “risks”
– Can provide assistance in the supply chain: logistics, warehousing and distribution

Disadvantages:

– Intellectual Property Rights
– Loose control over local markets
– Another entity that may require serious management oversight

Your exports become imports.

Recognize that your export will become an import for your customer overseas thus requiring an understanding of the basic import regulations of the countries you sell to. Maintain compliance with all the buyer’s country import regulations.

Documentation, packing, marking, labeling, formularizations are but some of the concerns.

Utilize the correct INCO Terms.

Learning the basics of INCO Terms is important, then applying that knowledge to ensure that you are utilizing the term best suited to meet the needs of your specific export transaction.

The seven Incoterms® 2020 rules for any mode(s) of transport are:

EXW Ex Works (insert place of delivery)
FCA Free Carrier (Insert named place of delivery)
CPT Carriage Paid to (insert place of destination)
CIP Carriage and Insurance Paid To (insert place of destination)
DAP Delivered at Place (insert named place of destination)
DPU Delivered at Place Unloaded (insert of place of destination)
DDP Delivered Duty Paid (Insert place of destination).

Note: the DPU Incoterm replaces the old DAT, with additional requirements for the seller to unload the goods from the arriving means of transport.

The four Incoterms® 2020 rules for Sea and Inland Waterway Transport are:

FAS Free Alongside Ship (insert name of port of loading)
FOB Free on Board (insert named port of loading)
CFR Cost and Freight (insert named port of destination)
CIF Cost Insurance and Freight (insert named proof of destination)

As a point of reference, if your intent is to sell where the customer picks the goods up at your place of origin, utilize FCA and not FOB or Ex Works, as you are likely to load the arriving conveyance.

Also keep in mind that trade compliance – rather than convenience – is often a more important driver of the choice of INCO Term.

Make sure you understand the 7 Basic Requirements to Reduce Risk in the Export Transaction.

1. Terms of Sale (INCO Term)
2. Terms of Payment
3. Insurance Requirements
4. Freight Handling
5. Compliance Responsibilities
6. Accounting for the Transaction (GAAP/IRS)
7. When “ownership” transfers

Utilize the correct Schedule B Number (HTSUS).

It is important to make sure you choose the correct Schedule B number, also referred to “HTS Number”. Your freight forwarder or consultant can guide you in this determination.

Understand the “Documentational Requirements”.

You are creating an export, which requires conformance with U.S. based export regulations. Simultaneously, you are facilitating an import overseas and thus must also comply with the import regulation of the country you are selling to.

Your freight forwarder or consultant can guide you in these documentary requirements.

Basic Export Documentation Requirements.

  • Ocean/Air Waybill
  • Domestic Bill of Lading/Drayage
  • Certificate of Conformity
  • Certificate of Origin
  • Commercial Invoice
  • Dock/Warehouse Receipt

Develop an Export Trade Compliance Mind-set.

You need to make sure you are complying with all export regulatory
requirements. Areas that need to be addressed include, but are not limited to, are as follows:

– Denied Parties Checking
– Destination Control Statements
– Ultimate Consignees
– Product Utilizations
– Destination Country Allowance
– Export License Requirements

Contracts of Sale/Agent/Distributor.

Utilize a professional consultant or attorney to guide you into these documents of agreement that will bind you to certain obligations.

1. The parties
2. The description of the products
3. Quality
4. Price per unit
5. Total value
6. Currency
7. Tax and Charges

8. Packing
9. Marking and Labelling
10. Mode of Transport
11.Delivery: Place and Schedule (INCO Term)
12. Insurance
13. Inspection
14. Documentation
15. Mode of Payment
16. Credit period, if any
17. Warranties
18. Passing of Risk
19. Passing of property
20. Export-Import Licenses
21. Force Majeure
22. Settlement of Disputes
23. Proper Law of the Contract
24. Jurisdiction

Protect your IPR.

Intellectual property (IP) refers to creations of the mind: inventions; literary and artistic works; and symbols, images, names, and logos used in commerce.

Businesses are often unaware that their business assets include IP rights.

Your intellectual property is a valuable intangible asset that should be protected to enhance your competitive advantage in the marketplace.

Stopfakes.gov is a one-stop shop for U.S. government tools and resources on intellectual property rights (IPR). You will find business guides, country toolkits, upcoming training events, and more on the site. See also export.gov.

How to Protect your IP

IP includes copyrights, which cover works of authorship, such as books, logos, and software. It also includes patents, which protect
inventions. Other types of IP include trademarks, designs, and trade secrets.

The first thing you need to do to safeguard your intellectual property is to file for protection in the United States. Your state’s
bar association can recommend experienced lawyers who can help you with that.

Then you must be the first inventor to file for protection in the countries in which you currently do business or are certain to do business in the future. You should also consider filing for protection in countries that are well-known for counterfeit markets.

If you do business in nations that have free trade agreements with the U.S., IP protections are built into those agreements, but you’ll still need to file in each country to get those protections.

Conversely, if you do business in any country in the European Union, you only need to file for protection with the EU – not every individual nation.

If you have a registered IP right in the United States, these protections are territorial and do not extend to foreign countries. Additionally, most countries are a “first to file” country for trademark registration and “first inventor to file” for patent registration and therefore grant registration to the first filer regardless of first use in the market.

Utilizing professional consultants and IPR counsel is also an excellent resource and likely go-to solution.

Utilize Quality Freight Forwarders.

Finding quality freight forwarders is necessary to develop a strong export capability.

Evaluation criteria:

Utilize a FF where you are a “bigger
fish in a smaller pond”

Strong Technology Capability

In Good Financial Shape

Global Reach

Experienced Personnel and Ease of Communication

Understand your “Landed Costs”.

Being competitive in export trade is important and knowing what all the costs are to get your goods from origin to destination will assist in that need.
Let us suppose the shipment of 100 units of a particular product arrives

  • Supplier cost: $20 per unit
  • Duty applicable at 4%
  • Freight cost for the entire shipment was $200 – and the specific product represents one-quarter of the shipment (1/4th of the total shipment)

Total Landed Cost = $20 + (4% x 20) + ((200 x 25%)/100) = 20+ 0.8 + .5 = $21.3 per unit

Landed cost formula:

Net Landed Cost = Supplier Cost + (Duty charges) + (Shipment charges specific to this product/total units)

Landed costs will help determine margins and profits and create the competitive leverage that may be required in competitive export sales.

Make sure the shipment is insured.

The risk of loss and damage is great in export trade. Depending upon the INCO Term and how payments are made will determine who need s to insure the transaction.

Cargo insurance should be “All Risk”, “Warehouse to Warehouse” through a reputable broker and underwriter who specialize in international insurance exposures and risk management.

Make sure you get paid

You need to be very diligent about getting paid. Having an unpaid export receivable can be very discouraging and problematic.

Options:

1. Consignment
2. Open Account (O/A)
3. Collections
4. Letter of Credit (L/C)
5. Cash in Advance

Working with your bank and your customer will help determine the best option. Accommodating clients’ needs balanced with potential risks is a good concept.

Export Credit Insurance.

Protect your export sales against nonpayment, offer open account credit terms to your buyers, and increase cash flow with EXIM’s export credit insurance.

There are also private insurance options such as with COFACE. We have specific contacts at COFACE we can refer you to.

The costs are low, the coverage is broad and is a great way to protect concern from foreign receivables.

Foreign Exchange Risk.

Reduce the risk associated with the uncertainty of future exchange rates. A good way is to quote prices and require payment in U.S. dollars.

Payment Problems.

Problems involving bad debts with your international buyer can set you back.
Avoid potential payment issues and tap key resources to limit risk and resolve problems.

Concluding Remarks.

This document is to be utilized only as a reference guide and starting point in understanding all the requirements of exporting. Accessing additional resources and expertise will be central to developing a successful export business capability.

The Author

Thomas A. Cook Is a 30-year seasoned veteran of global trade and Managing Director of Blue Tiger International, based in New York, LA and West Palm Beach, Florida. The author of 19 books on international business, two best business sellers.

Graduate of NYS Maritime Academy with an undergraduate and graduate degree in marine transportation and business management.

Tom has a worldwide presence through over 300 agents in every major city along with an array of transportation providers and solutions. Tom works with a number of Associations providing “value add” to their membership services and enhancing their overall reach into global sourcing and in export sales management.

FTZ The Port of Melbourne has announced major investments to expand terminal operations at Webb Dock East.

Foreign Trade Zones, Bonded Warehouses and Free Trade Agreements: Lowering Your “Landed Costs”

Foreign Trade Zones

FTZ’s have been an excellent source for lowering “landed costs” in face of increasing freight costs and long delays in the global supply chain, over the last two years due to the Pandemic and that impact which is now lasting well into 2022.

The primary reasons for considering FTZ’s in your global supply chain are:
– Ease of moving freight to and from the borders between trading           countries
– Reduction or elimination of duties, taxes and other import/export       costs
– Financial incentives on a local level
– Lowers the “landed costs” in your import/export business model
– Provides financial incentives that translates to lower operating             costs in your import and export transactions

There are other advantages that may be unique to geographic location and industry verticals.

The automotive industry which is dominated by foreign competition has been one of the major industry verticals to capitalize on FTZ’s here in the United States, as well as many countries abroad.

The basic FTZ model allows a company to manufacture or assemble finished products in a country abroad utilizing local labor for the specific purpose of reducing landed cost.

For example, a German car manufacturer sells a car in the U.S. for $50,000. Duties and taxes can add another $1500 to the landed cost.

Through the utilization of a FTZ strategically placed here in the United States. That German car manufacturer could import parts from Germany and utilize U.S labor to work in their U.S. factory.

Upon entry into the U.S. FTZ, duties and taxes on the parts are deferred. Upon assembly completion, the car leaves the FTZ for ultimate sale and that is when the deferred portion of the tax and duties are paid. If labor costs make up 50% of the $50,000 value, … only $25,000 is applicable to duty and tax.

This model (simplified by design for this article) reduces the “landed cost” by approximately $750.00 per vehicle. Compare this against 200,000 units and the savings could amount to over $150,000,000.00 annually.

There are numerous other benefits to FTZ’s that would need to be considered in any business model assessment.

In the above FTZ model, the utilization is assembly and manufacturing. More recent options allow high volume importers to have their goods pass through FTZ’s as they transit from the gateway through to their warehouses and distribution facilities.

This step allows a “weekly manifest clearance” which reduces entry fees and Merchandise Processing Fees (MPF) creating a significant financial savings impacting landed cost.

Consulting companies can help companies assess the benefits of an FTZ and weigh them against the costs and challenges to make it happen.

Bonded Warehouses

Another option, similar to but different from a FTZ is the “Bonded Warehouse”. Bonded warehouses are a supply chain option which allows importers and exporters to temporarily hold freight where the import is deferred along with duties, taxes and other import costs, until such time the goods enter the country or are exported from that country.

For example, let’s take a Cleveland based electronics distributor importing consumer music products from Asia, totaling over 200m annually with an average duty rate of 4.5 %. Approximately 20% of the products are then re-exported to Canada, the Caribbean and Latin America.

Under their current supply chain model, they utilize CBP’s drawback program to obtain up to 99% of the duties and taxes for those exports, totaling 1.8m annually. While drawback is a great program, it can be arduous and costly to manage and takes time to receive the refund of duties.

As an alternative, the distributor can apply to CBP to make their warehousing facility a bonded location. This will defer the duties and taxes to goods entering the warehouse to the point in time they are extracted from the facility.

Additionally, the 20% of the goods that are re-exported come in and leave the USA in bond and no duties or taxes are obligated to be paid providing significant savings in supply chain costs.

Bonded warehouses provide additional benefits, but the operations permitted in a bonded warehouse are limited so sorting, weighing and repacking. If the goods enter the warehouse as a widget, they must leave as a widget.

For Bonded versus FTZ … four steps must be completed to decide which may present the best option to the principal company.

These four steps allow a detailed assessment of the options, the benefits and challenges, a ROI, an operational overview … followed by implementation.

The process can take from 60-180 Days and will have costs involved in all the steps that are typically outweighed from the residual and ongoing financial benefits.

Free Trade Agreements (FTA’s)

FTA’s offer numerous advantages to both importers and exporters. Currently the U.S. participates in over thirteen agreements with numerous ones pending. The most well-known FTA is USMCA (Previously called NAFTA), which has consistently provided overwhelming ROI to Canada, Mexico and the United States.

When the three participating countries … USA, Canada and Mexico trade with one another there is a serious reduction of duties and taxes on qualified goods and merchandise.

The most advantageous benefit in the FTA’s is the free movement of goods between participating countries where duties and taxes are reduced or eliminated.

“Near Sourcing” is the recent phenomenon in global trade where trade is coming back to the USA or our USMCA partners. FTA’s provide a more level playing field, particularly against lower Asian based sourcing models.

Lower freight costs, reduced lead times and elimination of duties and taxes can very easily make manufacturing in Mexico or in a USA based FTZ … a much more competitive option, thereby leveraging critical logistics business model options.

Mexico enjoys a “Maquiladora Program” which greatly enhances USMCA benefits where manufacturing and assembly is done in Mexico for goods which will eventually be shipped to the USA.

Other countries such as but not limited to:

Australia                                                     Bahrain

Canada                                                        Chile
Colombia                                                   Costa Rica
Dominican  Republic                           El Salvador
Guatemala                                                Honduras
Israel                                                            Jordan
Korea                                                           Mexico
Morocco                                                    Nicaragua
Oman                                                          Panama
Peru                                                             Singapore

When searching out trading partners as sourcing or selling options … Free Trade Agreement Countries can provide competitive advantage to the buyers and sellers.

As political problems increase with China and disruptions in trade happen now with what we have with Russia … it makes the case for American Companies to buy and sell from trading partners where there are more favorable and sustainable working environments … and that can be leveraged to each party’s advantage.

global supply chain

Resilience in the Global Supply Chain: Understanding 5 Key Ingredients

Resilience is defined as follows:

re·sil·ience

/rəˈzilyəns/

noun

1. the capacity to recover quickly from difficulties; toughness. “the often remarkable resilience of so many British institutions”

2.  the ability of a substance or object to spring back into shape; elasticity. “nylon is excellent in wearability and resilience”

In terms of global supply chains, resilience is determined by an ability to adapt, survive and perform despite devastating and unplanned circumstances such as those we have been dealing with since the Covid-19 pandemic enveloped the world in February 2020.

The Covid-19 pandemic has been disruptive to every company, in every business vertical, in all countries, to all companies and for most people in the world.

The impacts of increased delays, cost escalations, unavailable space, reduced inventory balances, and lost sales continued to escalate through 2021, a year that we hoped would have positioned the pandemic in our rear-view mirrors.

By contrast, the economic impact, as well as the personal toll, have been devastating, and as we enter 2022 the residual concerns are lingering and in some business models are worsening.

Delays, cost escalations and uncertainty plague all global supply chains and have made for very difficult daily management and long-term planning.

All these issues are challenges that must be met by the supply chain executives who manage these responsibilities for the companies they operate in.

Having been through numerous disasters that have impacted supply chains, from hurricanes to tsunamis to winter storms … this pandemic has exposed corporations to new and extended vulnerabilities, never previously seen to this magnitude.

Over the last 35 years and especially in the last 20 months, I have witnessed and participated in various strategies, methodologies, and tactics to deal with these challenges.

An individual’s demonstration of “RESILIENCE” has been a key ingredient to surviving these challenges and keeping his or her organization on an even keel through these turbulent waters.

I believe there are 5 Key Ingredients to “Resiliency in Global Supply Chains”.

-Patience

-Pliability

-Information & Research Gain

-Creative Solutions

-Going Back to Basics

Patience

Those that are too quick to respond under the pressure of the issues and under senior management demands will likely make misjudgments that will make matters worse.

As an example: A logistics manager is losing patience with their service provider, who is having difficulty booking space. Instead of trying collaboratively to find a solution … moves the business to another freight forwarder … to only discover that the new forwarder’s senior management team is prioritizing space allocations to older clients and not new ones.

The logistics manager has now created a bigger hole to get out of.

Exercising patience, along with a collaborative approach, would more likely have brought a resolution that could now be in play. The impatience moved the potential resolution to the back of the line.

Patience comes with maturity, confidence, and experience. Junior-level supply chain personnel lacking tenure need to closely observe senior management – who are hopefully setting an example of a more balanced reaction and approach to disaster.

Reactions by instinct alone, hurried responses and not well-thought-out actions will typically lead to poor choices. Poor choices produce bad outcomes.

Through this pandemic, I have observed many company supply chain executives – both young and old – overreact and make some bad decisions, which placed their supply chain in further jeopardy.

“Patience is a Virtue” is part of an old adage that has never rung truer than in managing global supply chains in 2020, 2021 and into 2022.

Pliability

Pliability is the ability to bend, like a willow tree in the wind. It is all about flexibility, like a gymnast performing at this year’s Summer Olympics in Tokyo.

In Supply Chain, the meaning moves us in a direction where our strategies, tactics and decisions must become molded to the new circumstances we face where demand and capacity have been misaligned for over the past 20 months and likely to continue down that road well into 2022.

It means we must adapt to a completely new set of assessments, quantitative data input, expected outcomes, and circumstances mostly out of our control.

Specifically, in companies with a global footprint, this means underperforming suppliers, unreliable freight services, escalating costs and enormous frustrations in promises made by many and kept by few.

In addition to being patient, in this pandemic, the supply chain executive must take well-thought-out risks and approaches that can offer resolutions to all the obstacles and challenges.

And more importantly, it means that we must be pliable in our approach to attempt solutions not previously tried.

Information and Resource Gain

The Supply Chain Executives showing resilience will have to make better decisions. Better decisions will originate with quantitative data analysis, based on robust information flows.

As an example: A procurement manager for a perfume company that has a major supplier in Guangzhou, China, which accounts for 80% of a particular product line.

The Chinese supplier is having trouble meeting demand. The intuitive procurement manager dives deep with the supplier to find out who supplies them with the raw materials that they seem to be having trouble obtaining in the necessary quantities needed to fill their PO’s.

The procurement manager reached into their sourcing staff to see if they can find some alternative suppliers, which they were successful doing.

This new raw material supplier to their supplier made a big difference in having them mitigate the problems of meeting all the PO requirements.

Information, along with collaboration, resolved the problem.

In today’s world, information can make the difference between success and failure, profit or loss. Supply Chain Managers need to spend considerable time in developing resources to gain information.

Some of these resources could be:

-Friendly competitors

-Supply Chain Organizations: CSCMP, ISM, NIWT, etc.

-Consultants specializing in Global Supply Chain: Blue Tiger International & others

-Internet (search, networking)

-Media: Journal of Commerce, American Shipper & SupplyChainBrain

-Industry Trade Shows

-Advanced Colleges & Universities with Supply Chain Modules

Information that provides useful data comes from reliable sources, comprehensive structure, timely subject matter and from qualified expertise.

The “Gain of Information” is invaluable in making informed and well-thought-out decisions.  Resourcefulness is making clever use of the information gained.

Creative Solutions

This is a time one needs to raise the bar of performance in meeting the Covid-19 Pandemic challenges.

Solutions of the past may not have contemporary applications. Current practices may make the problems even worse.

One needs to “put on the thinking cap” and bring new and creative ideas to the table.

This is directly tied into being patient, pliable, and developing information sources and resources, previously discussed.

An example: A NY-based chemical company operating successfully for 40+ years is having difficulty moving cargo timely and cost-effectively from various Asian suppliers.

Their typical move is product in 25 and 50 Kilo bags and boxes, stowed in 20- and 40-Foot Containers.

They are feeling the pain of 90-120 delays in ocean freight and cost escalations from $2700/per 40’ to $22,500/per 40’ from March of 2020 till now in December 2021.

The delay and cost escalation are devastating the cost-effectiveness in an established supply chain that has worked well for more than 40 years.

The potential of customer loss is great along with margin depletion.

They collaborated with a supply chain consultant who suggested they load the product in 500 kilo super sacks at their supplier facilities and “charter” a Breakbulk vessel to move 20’ container volumes of freight.

This was very much out of their wheelhouse, but they diligently, along with their consultant reviewed the risks, quantified, assessed carefully and took steps to mitigate all the challenges that came to light.

Now, 8 months later, they have had 3 successful charters and have actually reduced landed costs by 10-12%. Their margins are in-line, the customers are happy.  The new and creative approach, with well-thought-out risk management steps, came to a favorable conclusion.

In another example: A Houston-based consumer electronics company purchasing finished products from all over the world, specifically from suppliers in Europe, Asia and the Middle East.

In their standard (pre-pandemic) process, they would bring the goods into their 750,000 sq.ft. distribution facility just outside Houston for quality control work before shipping product to customers in all 50 states, Mexico and Canada. Most customers were big-box retailers.

In this case, their supply chain consultant gave them two suggestions which they studied, assessed, and modified to fit their supply chain; both of which ultimately created favorable outcomes.

For the first option, they approached their larger retailers who were building their own consolidations in the countries they were sourcing from.

They offered the retailers pricing discounts to move the sales from CIF INCO Term to FCA Overseas Consolidation Point. Meaning they would deliver the goods to the warehouse/carrier at the outbound gateway of the country of origin. The retailer would take possession of the goods at their consolidation facility and combine it with other orders and ship as a “consolidated shipment”. The benefits could be freight cost savings and affording the control of the cargo directly to the consignee.

The second suggestion was to make the distribution facility in Houston into a Foreign Trade Zone (FTZ), where duties on sales to US entities were deferred until point of sale.  For goods exported to Canada and Mexico, no duties were paid, as the goods passed through the FTZ and never entered the U.S. economy.

This option took approximately 3 months to assess and implement, and an upgrade in their supply chain technologies became a favored solution.

Other creative solutions are as follows:

All these options present potential solutions to the global supply chain management teams to consider in mitigating the impact of disruptions and to lower landed costs.

Going Back to Basics

I was an athlete throughout my high school and college years, rising to “All American” status. I observed many times when athletic prowess waivered, winning subsided, and performance shattered how the coaches brought us back from the “dark side”.

Experience demonstrates that difficult times are likely to occur. Success is not a straight and smooth line. It is curved, bumpy and has roadblocks.

I observed over the years that quality coaches had the ability to turn circumstances around and bring guidance, solutions and resolve to the challenges we faced.

Their number one solution was to bring the team and the athlete back to basics. In soccer, it was dribbling, passing and running. In wrestling it was take-downs, grinding and stamina build-up, in lacrosse, it was throwing, cradling and scooping.

Practice those basic skill sets and once achieved again, move forward onto more robust capabilities and strategies.

It was a formula that worked over and over again. In my adult life, I utilize the same strategy in golf. When my game goes south I go back to basics: slow the swing, keep the head down and work on the short game.

The basics in global supply chain are:

Summary

We believe … like tragic forest fires that ultimately benefit the woodlands as old timber is destroyed allowing new and stronger growth to eventually flourish … that weak supply chains will potentially be lost and stronger supply chains will survive and prosper.

So it will be for global supply chains.  This latest unprecedented disruption will make supply chains ultimately operate with:

-Greater Efficiencies

-More cost-effective strategies

-Enhanced processes, protocols and SOP’s for future disruptions and affording proactive mitigation strategies

All leading to a mindset of “resiliency” … a great management quality allowing not only survival but growth and prosperity … in the most difficult of times.

 ______________________________________________________________________

Thomas A. Cook is a 30 year seasoned veteran of global trade and Managing Director of Blue Tiger International, based in New York, LA and West Palm Beach, Florida.

The author of 19 books on international business, two best business sellers. Graduate of NYS Maritime Academy with an undergraduate and graduate degree in marine transportation and business management.

Tom has a worldwide presence through over 300 agents in every major city along with an array of transportation providers and solutions.

Tom works with a number of Associations providing “value add” to their membership services and enhancing their overall reach into global sourcing and in export sales management.

He can be reached at tomcook@bluetigerintl.com or 516-359-6232

global trade shortage chain supply rose disruption identity

Spotlight on Supply Chain Management: Raising the Profile & Importance of the Supply Chain Manager

Supply chain management has become a much more important business function in all companies since the pandemic began in February 2020. Let’s frame the issues which have made this executive and management change occur.

The Covid-19 pandemic has been devastating to the performance of both domestic and global supply chains. The disruption, uncertainty, cost escalations, and delays which began in March 2020, continue into the fall of 2021.

The crisis caused by a disturbing and unanticipated imbalance between demand and supply in all world markets has resulted in unprecedented challenges facing all managers and operations personnel engaged in the supply chain, procurement, manufacturing, warehousing, logistics, transportation, customer service, import/export, and sales.

The challenges and their impact extend to all the support functions to supply chains: service providers, freight forwarders, carriers, 3PL’s, technology providers, consolidators, and distributors.

While the supply chain has generally had a “subordinated” posture in most companies, the Pandemic has now elevated this area of responsibility because the consequences of poor performance and failure are so impactful in the success of a business’s margin, profit, growth, and sustainability.

The importance of this area runs equally now to the importance of the supply chain manager, who may be known under the various “Titles” in the organization. Supply Chain, Procurement, Logistics, Warehousing & Distribution, Manufacturing, Materials Management, Demand Planning, etc.

With this “increase in importance”:

The disruption has impacted every company, executive, and business vertical. And we must also acknowledge the consequences to people and their families.

The impact to supply chains has moved up the ladder in every company all the way to the CEO, The Board, and the Shareholders.

In our consulting practice, where 90% of the time we deal with mid-level managers, in the last 20 months, my team and I have met with more CEOs than we have in the last ten years.

Supply Chain Managers and their colleagues have been forced due to the disorder in their business models, to work harder, work smarter and ultimately bring resources, experiences, and capabilities to the benefit of the disruptive impacts of the Pandemic.

Supply Chain Managers have been now tested in areas as never seen previously. Most companies, over time, have seen physical, weather-related geopolitical events impact their supply chains. Negative events happen all the time. While we have had some more notable micro-events in the supply chain in the last 10-15 years:

-The Recession of 2008/9

-Hurricane Sandy in 2012

-The 2011 Tsunami in Japan

-Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans in 2005

-Global Wildfires 2019

-Sichuan Earthquake in China in 2008

-South and Mid-West USA Tornados in 2013

-Mississippi River Flooding 2011

-Northeast Winter Storm in 2018

-The current Covid-19 Pandemic 2020-?

The impact on people, business, and the costs in billions and trillions from all these events is unthinkable. And the challenges that faced businesses and supply chain managers were dramatic.

However, this Pandemic has presented a unique set of circumstances:

-Every country and every person and business are impacted

-Personnel working from home has changed communications, team efforts, camaraderie and in some cases increased effectiveness and performance

-The tenure, now passing 20 months

-The uncertainty of planning out supply chain functions

-Demand Planning is almost impossible

-Lean Manufacturing and “Just in Time” Inventory Management Systems, have been retired

-All business models are being strained resulting in alternative and modified structures

-Managers and staff are working longer hours, becoming “burnt out” is a serious reality

-Hiring has been impaired

-Margins, profits, growth, and sustainability are all being challenged

With all these concerns having been identified as the “new reality” the good news is that many organizations’ talents, particularly in supply chain functions are finding ways to meet these challenges and maintaining their company’s business models to a necessary extent of successful operations.

Supply Chain Managers have become creative in their approach and along with companies like ours, Blue Tiger International, have found solutions to mitigate the impact of the Pandemic.

We have developed 14 Solutions, collaboratively with our supply chain managers. Some of these are:

The new roles and responsibilities of The Pandemic Supply Chain Manager require them to “think-out-of-the-box” and create approaches that were never thought of or utilized previously.

At Blue Tiger International, we become an extension of the supply chain manager’s resources and provide a business model to evaluate these options and apply them to the uniqueness of their business models and supply chains.

The four steps profiled above start with an overall assessment of the domestic and global supply chain. That review provides some solutions which must be tied into a financial evaluation that defines ROI.

This is followed by an operational review which determines what changes in the companies supply chain and business model require modification to meet the solution requirements. As an example, if it was assessed and evidenced ROI, the company choosing a Foreign Trade Zone as an option, it is likely changes would be made to the functions of compliance, security, product accountability, technology, and business process.

The last step is implementation, working collaboratively to make the solution work to the benefit of the business model.

This is all unfertile ground to the Supply Chain Executive. What we have observed is a significant “rise to the occasion” of many supply chain personnel, managers and executives to meet and successfully manage these required changes.

They are not necessarily eliminating the issues, but they are providing mitigating strategies all in the name of protecting market share, margins and sustainability.

Supply Chain Managers have become “Frontline Heroes” in the face of this Pandemic and deserve much credit and recognition for keeping supply chains functioning in the face of all these challenges.

This has and will continue to “raise the profile & importance” of Supply Chain Management in all companies’ business models. Additionally, senior management is recognizing their value to the organization, which has been a long-time coming.

________________________________________________________________

Thomas A. Cook is a 30 year seasoned veteran of global trade and Managing Director of Blue Tiger International, based in New York, LA and West Palm Beach, Florida.

The author of 19 books on international business, two best business sellers. Graduate of NYS Maritime Academy with an undergraduate and graduate degree in marine transportation and business management.

Tom has a worldwide presence through over 300 agents in every major city along with an array of transportation providers and solutions.

Tom works with a number of Associations providing “value add” to their membership services and enhancing their overall reach into global sourcing and in export sales management.

He can be reach at tomcook@bluetigerintl.com or 516-359-6232

supply chain

Navigating the 12 Pitfalls of the Global Supply Chain

With over 30+ years of international trade experience, I have witnessed numerous and repeated errors made by Sales, Purchasing, Logistics Managers, Supply Chain, and International Business Executives.

There are tremendous opportunities and benefits to be derived through global sourcing and foreign business development. Along with these opportunities are considerable challenges, obstacles, and pitfalls. In order to succeed in international business, management must mitigate these concerns through gaining knowledge and implementing processes and controls over import and export operations, including the development of robust training for all personnel.

The following section contains twelve steps companies can take to manage the solutions that will allow the navigation through these challenges and delivering success to the international operation.

These twelve steps create a pathway forward in a concise, straightforward methodology and time-tested process to ensure management accomplishes their desired corporate goals of profits, growth, and sustainability.

Avoid the following:

Step 1: “We have no personal liability”.

There is significant personal liability for individuals who operate in global supply chains.

U.S. Government enforcement agencies, such as but not limited to:

– Department of Justice

– Customs and Border Protection

– Departments of State, Commerce and Treasury

– Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms

– United States Department of Agriculture and the Food and Drug Administration

All above are a few of the agencies that will prosecute both organizations and individuals who are seriously out of trade compliance with their import and export regulatory responsibilities.

While criminal prosecution is a rare occurrence … it does happen every day in the supply chain, somewhere in the world of international trade.

Trade Compliance Management in companies with an international footprint is a necessary evil that needs to be managed and integrated into the fabric of the organization’s culture and business model.

Step 2: “The FOB Term is Always a Safe Incoterm to Utilize”.

The FOB Incoterm has three deadly areas of concern:

-It is used in domestic trade

-It is a gray area in the loading process

-There can be ambiguity when the point in time responsibility and liability shift from the seller to the buyer (exporter to importer).

It is used in domestic trade

For domestic trade in the United States, the UCCP (Uniform Commercial Code of Practice) currently (though in contention) utilizes the FOB term as a “term of sale or purchase”, where there are two primary options FOB Origin and FOB Destination.

Within the UCCP, FOB is defined as:

Uniform Commercial Code › U.C.C. – ARTICLE 2 – SALES (2002) › PART 3. GENERAL OBLIGATION AND CONSTRUCTION OF CONTRACT

2-319. F.O.B. and F.A.S. Terms.

Unless otherwise agreed the term F.O.B. (which means “free on board”) at a named place, even though used only in connection with the stated price, is a delivery term under which:

(a) when the term is F.O.B. the place of shipment, the seller must at that place ship the goods in the manner provided in this Article (Section 2-504) and bear the expense and risk of putting them into the possession of the carrier; or

(b) when the term is F.O.B. the place of destination, the seller must at his own expense and risk transport the goods to that place and their tender delivery of them in the manner provided in this Article (Section 2-503);

(c) when under either (a) or (b) the term is also F.O.B. vessel, car, or another vehicle, the seller must in addition at his own expense and risk load the goods on board. If the term is F.O.B. vessel the buyer must name the vessel and in an appropriate case, the seller must comply with the provisions of this Article on the form of a bill of lading (Section 2-323).

The UCCP Term allows any mode of transit or conveyance.

Some sources claim that FOB stands for “Freight on Board”. This is not the case. “Freight On Board” is not mentioned in any version of Incoterms, and is not defined by the Uniform Commercial Code in the USA.[10] Further to that, it has been found in court that “Freight On Board” is not a recognized industry term.[11] The use of “Freight on Board” in contracts is therefore very likely to cause confusion. The correct term is “free onboard”.

Keep in mind that a huge amount, if not a clear majority of domestic commercial transactions, are sold or purchased on a FOB basis and moved by truck, rail, or air. This would be ok if the FOB Term was the UCCP intent and not intended utilization under Incoterms 2020.

There is a very clear line of confusion between the domestic and international “FOB” terms in selling and purchasing. It is only when it causes a problem when it is seen as an issue.

Free on Board, or FOB is an Incoterm, which means the seller is responsible for loading the purchased cargo onto the ship, and all costs associated with same. At the point, the goods are safely onboard the vessel, the risk transfers to the buyer, who assumes the responsibility of the remainder of the transport.

FOB is the most common agreement between an international buyer and seller when shipping cargo via sea. This Incoterm only applies to sea and inland waterway shipments.

The 2020 edition of Incoterms opened the door for domestic utilization of the FOB term. The FOB UCCP term varies greatly from the FOB Incoterm.

Under Incoterms 2020, the preferred term for domestic utilization, since that door was opened, is FCA (Free Carrier At).

It is a gray area in the loading process

Under Incoterms 2000 and prior, the FOB term transferred risk and cost from the seller to the buyer once the goods passed the ship’s rail.

This factor was changed in the 2010 edition of Incoterms and continues in the 2020 edition. The term now read “…passes when the goods are on board the vessel”.

However, “on board” is not clearly defined. Is that when the goods are placed on the deck, in the hold, not yet secured, secured, etc.?

We had a case in our office, where a U.S. exporter, sold a huge piece of equipment, (25 Tons, $11m in value) to a customer in Europe. It was going to be shipped via ocean, secured in a cargo hold under deck.

During the loading process, the goods were being lifted onto the vessel by a crane and longshoreman crew. In the handling, the equipment was laid down on the deck of the hold several times, while the longshoreman positioned the cargo.

In that repositioning process, the freight was damaged. The issue now became who is responsible, based upon the Incoterm of FOB Port Elizabeth – the seller or the buyer?

Were the goods actually “on board” when they were damaged? The maritime judicial system will eventually resolve that issue and court precedence will be established.

But today there is an ambiguity in defining “on board” in the FOB Incoterm. There are references to being “secured in place”, but it appears ambiguous.

Sellers and buyers need to address these specific concerns in the contract of sale and attempt to minimize the gray areas of liability, that may present themselves when using the FOB term.

There can be ambiguity when the point in time responsibility and liability shift from the seller to the buyer (exporter to importer).

This is the explanation of the FOB term from the Incoterms 2020 edition.

A2 (Delivery)

The seller delivers by placing the goods on board the vessel nominated or provided by the buyer on the agreed date, or within the agreed period as notified by the buyer, or if there is no such time notified then at the end of that period.

There is still a belief that the ship’s rail is the defining point, i.e.: before the notional vertical line above the rail is the seller’s cost and risk, and after is the buyer’s cost and risk. A court ruled that the delivery point was when the goods were on the deck but that then caused the question was the notional vertical line replaced with a notional horizontal one in line with the deck itself and what if the goods were being placed below deck? This ship’s rail concept was removed in the Incoterms® 2010 version. Typically, then, “on board” is taken to mean when the goods are safely on the deck or in the hold. If the cargo needs to be then further secured for transportation such as being lashed or separated with some material or spread evenly throughout the hold for bulk goods like grain the seller and buyer should agree in their contract what is needed and at whose cost and risk this is done.

B2 (Delivery)

The buyer’s obligation is to take delivery when the goods have been delivered as described in A2.

FOB A3 / B3: Transfer of Risk

A3 (Transfer of risk)

In all the rules the seller bears all risks of loss or damage to the goods until they have been delivered in accordance with A2 described above. The exception is loss or damage in circumstances described in B3 below, which varies depending on the buyer’s role in B2

B3 (Transfer of risk)

The buyer bears all risks of loss or damage to the goods once the seller has delivered them as described in A2.

If the buyer fails to inform the seller of where and when the vessel will be presented or if the vessel fails to arrive on time, or it fails to take the goods so that the seller cannot deliver, then the buyer bears the risk of loss or damage to the goods from the agreed date or at the end of the agreed period.

On an operational level, the seller delivered the goods to the terminal, carrier, or other agreed named place, and the goods were not loaded on board as anticipated for an array of reasons, such as but not limited to the carriers having vessel timing or loading issues and the seller appropriately notified the buyer than delivery has been made and risk of loss and damage has passed from the seller to the buyer.

The important aspect to note here is that the buyer expected to take delivery “on board” and now that did not occur as the buyer will take delivery and assume all risks at a point short of “on board”.

In general, Incoterms need to be understood in their entirety including the consequences associated with using the incorrect Incoterm or not understanding the specific responsibilities as the buyer or seller. Incoterms training is a must for all personnel engaged in global trade and more particularly those operating in Procurement, Sales, Operations, Finance, and Customer Service.

Companies involved in international trade using best practices will switch Incoterms 2020 rules in quotations, purchase orders, contracts, commercial invoices, and other commercial documentation when determining the level of responsibilities and costs they want to take on; dividing the responsibilities for risk transfer, costs, and responsibility for carrier selection between the buyer and the seller.

Step 3: Contracts Override Relationships

In international trade, relationships trump contracts. Relationships will drive a successful deal and a long tenure. I have always extolled “you can contract out risk”, but you can seriously minimize and mitigate risk by establishing favored relationships that allow the best opportunity for problem resolution and working out issues that will likely occur over time and trade.

Contracts are important to make the deal have legal standing, but it is foolish to believe that the contract eliminates any risk in the transaction. In fact, sometimes contracts can cause risk when a false sense of security is at hand.

Obtaining legal support is prudent but spending money and time at building relationships with suppliers, vendors, agents, and customers will go a long way in mitigating many of the risks in global trade.

Step 4: Service Providers are Experts in all Aspects of the Global Supply Chain

Just not so! While a small percentage of service providers are clearly experts, professionals, and aligned with teams of knowledgeable staff the majority have serious limitations.

While many have the expertise to arrange affreightment, pick up and delivery many lacks:

-the necessary local connections in all foreign markets

-trade compliance knowledge

-an understanding of how best to eliminate risk and cost from the supply chain

A high degree of scrutiny, vetting, and discerning should take place when choosing service providers, 3PL’s, freight forwarders, and customhouse brokers.

Areas of evaluation:

Service providers can be very valued partners in your global supply chain. Just because they hang out a shingle does not mean they can provide real benefit. Scrutinize robustly and vet diligently. It will pay off in the long run. Having a quality partner will make your job easier and with a greater ability to meet all the challenges successfully.

Step 5: Manage the Supply Chain with Robust Technology

Supply chains that have expansive technology in every aspect of the operation will gain great leverage in performance metrics.

Areas of technology in the supply chain are:

Technology creates efficiency, ease of operations, robust information flow, security, and other benefits. It allows for the highest levels of performance in any organization, but more particularly in the global supply chain. Technology advances forward and expands every day. Keeping contemporary is a challenge that all supply chain executives face.

Cyber Security has grown to be a significant threat. It must be contemplated and managed in every moment and keystroke of the day. There are cybersecurity solutions that must be integrated into all aspects of operation, where there is a technology interface.

Step 6: We have been doing it this way … for over 5 years with no problems.

We hear this often and clearly because a company has not encountered a specific problem, does not necessarily mean things are being done correctly.

A volcano is not a problem until it erupts. The underlying problem is waiting for emergence. Dealing with potential issues proactively and anticipating “what ifs” are a much better option.

Potential problems along with potential betterments must be proactively pursued to assure you do not have serious issues and are doing all possible to reduce risk and cost and/or business process improvements.

Continually updating a logistic SWOT Analysis, risk management assessments and process evaluations are all necessary steps in mitigating any unanticipated problems in the future.

Because no one is complaining does not mean everything is ok. You must be proactive in making sure everything is ok, without assumptions. Err to the side of conservativism as it will prevent future headaches.

The pandemic was a complete disaster and disruption to all global supply chains. Having said that, some good came out of it as companies had time for internal introspection at risk and threats leading to proactive steps in mitigation.

Step 7: We Handed it to the Carrier, so it must be “on board”

Tracking and tracing need to be accomplished at a very detailed and exhaustive level.

Just because you have confirmation that a carrier has received freight, does not assure it made it on board the vessel, aircraft, railcar or truck.

You need affirmation that in fact the goods have actually made it on board the conveyance with an updated ETA, followed up with daily frequency, in case of any unanticipated delays, which occur all the time.

Step 8: We Always Check the Denied Parties List

Many international executives believe their companies are consistently checking and reviewed the various lists making up the “Denied Party Screening” regulations for importers and exporters.

In many years of auditing companies engaged in global trade, only a small percentage is fully compliant with the review, checking and compliance responsibilities associated with Denied Party Screening.

There are available direct connections into the government agencies and numerous third-party technology companies with DPL Screening Capabilities.

Step 9: I am the Ultimate Consignee on these Goods, but not the Importer of Record.

Many companies who are the recipients of imported merchandise who are not participative in the import process believe they have no import responsibilities.

That is potentially and totally incorrect! Customs (CBP) has the right to evaluate any import situation and determine that the ultimate consignee could be considered the “importer of record” and therefore has all the responsibilities as the “importer of record”. This would then require adherence to all import regulations HTSUS, valuation, recordkeeping, etc.

Step 10: Domestic Packing will work for my International Shipments

Claims for loss and damage on international shipments occur every day and a major cause is inadequate packing, marking and labeling.

Just check with any marine insurance companies they will advise of the frequency and the severity of claims occurring on import and export shipments directly attributed to inadequate packing marking and labeling which could jeopardize marine cargo insurance coverage as an implicit or explicit warranty.

Step 11: Do we really need to ensure the shipment?

Loss and damage to international freight is a daily occurrence worldwide. In the overall cost of the global supply chain, marine insurance is an inexpensive purchase offering a high value of the return.

Just looked at what happened this year in the Suez Canal, with the grounding of the Ever Given (Evergreen Lines) which potentially caused losses in excess of $ 1billion.

Direct claims in delays and damage and indirectly caused by a General Average Claim. The fines, penalties, delays and lost cargo is still mounting, as only in early July, has the vessel finally exited the Suez Canal.

Marine cargo insurance is a solid, responsible, value-driven, and best practice purchase for any company shipping goods internationally.

“All Risk”, “Warehouse to Warehouse” with contemporary customized underwriting terms under standard policies are available.

Step 12: Do I need to train my global supply chain team?

The challenges of the global supply chain are numerous and daunting. These challenges can only be met by experienced well-trained managers and staff. The training needs to be consistent, contemporary and robust. Key areas to include are:

-Compliance

-Documentation

-Negotiating Freight

-Sourcing Management

-Logistics Management

-Technology Management

-Warehousing & Distribution

-International Contracts

-Risk and Spend Directives

-Foreign Trade Zones

These outlined above show a handful of the necessary skill sets required for import and export personnel to master. And “training” is the pathway to successful global supply chain management.

Summary:

The twelve examples outlined above provide a synopsis and evidence that mistakes based upon a lack of knowledge and skillsets can cause great disruption in import and export activity in the global supply chain.

Developing resources, providing training, and implementing procedures will assist in mitigating the problems and challenges identified in the above article.

Resources in international business and supply chain management will provide informed intelligence that will allow for making better decisions.

Training and skill set development will better prepare supply chain, import & export executives, managers, and staff to better deal successfully with all the challenges of global trade.

Procedures, protocols, and disciplines in management are always critical to a company’s success in business. In the global supply chain, SOPs are an integral component of freight, logistics, trade compliance, foreign sales, and overseas procurement that assure a company’s success in its international footprint.

The author can be reached at: tomcook@bluetigerintl.com for questions and comments.

global supply

Global Supply Chain Management: Developing Successful Relationships in Freight and Logistics

The Covid-19 Pandemic has increased in global supply chains:

-Uncertainty

-Increased Costs

-Delays

-Reduced Capacity

-Limited Negotiation Leverage for Shippers

When freight is managed as a “commodity” there is little opportunity for long-term, more successful and profitable relationships in the purchasing of global transportation services between shippers of cargo, service providers and carriers.

Most shippers with international footprints work directly with carrier options, NVOCC’s, 3PL’s or forwarders/brokers. These relationships, as we enter the second year of the Covid-19 Pandemic are increasingly critical aspects of freight, logistics and overall supply chain management success.

Uncertainty in the freight markets has created a disruption, confusion, and disharmony in the trade lanes of the world, in particular, to and from the USA/China. Air and Ocean Freight Pricing is up in multiples of 3-8x average pricing over the 2017-2019 periods.

There are also delays and a significant lack of carrier capacity, chassis and trucking capabilities. This has impacted both imports and exports as well as certain domestic movements.

While the biggest impact is on international trade lanes, domestic freight is up and has caused capacity and pricing increase, as well.

The most impactful frustration is with inbound air and ocean freight from China to North America. The concerns start with the “demand planning” and the need to substantially increase lead times, say normally at 8-12 weeks to 20-30 weeks out.

Importers need to be prepared for delays in moving the freight as much as 30-60 days. Carriers have now come up with “Premium Pricing” best described as “If you want your freight to move … this is the price you will have to pay”. This is causing ocean freight pricing to rise into the $8-15,000 level per 40’ Container from China to the West Coast USA.

Ocean Freight which has been typically guided by “annual contracts” is now mainly controlled by “spot market pricing”. Another leading indicator of a very tight market condition.

Airfreight pricing could as high as $10.00 per kilo., where normally $2.50 per kilo would be the market rates.

The market volatility is likely to extend into 2022 so we caution all supply chain managers to properly prepare for more difficult times and seek numerous options.

With all the doom and gloom, there are a number of measures we can take to mitigate the impact and

When we have “sustainable relationships” we capitalize on the following:

Better working relationships between shippers, service providers, and carriers

We all want to work in an atmosphere in global trade where we would describe our relationships in the global supply chain as excellent. This allows for less stress and overall better results.

Quality relationships create the ability for better planning and management by more informed and better-anticipated expectations.

Ability to work through Pandemic Disruption.

Carriers and Service Providers are more likely to accommodate existing clients where a favorable working relationship is present. Since there is limited capacity, the industry prioritizes clients over prospects.

Longer tenured relationships

Changing service providers and carriers frequently is disruptive and costly and never a preferred option. Everyone engaged in the supply chain does better in long-term relationships.

Reduction of risk and spend in the global supply chain

When the relationships work well we always see a direct relationship to the reduction of costs and risks as goods move through the supply chain cycle both domestically and internationally

Keep in mind that there are a number of options from freight consolidation, drawbacks, FTZ’s … that these relationships can bring to value in global supply chains.

Consistency in pricing and service agreements

If we always have “spikes” and “steep” changes in our business models, no one will be happy in your company and the difficulty to manage operational issues will be very difficult all the time.

The preference always is to have a smooth gliding more rhythmic path in the business model to follow so changes are not large or small but even out on a more consistent basis.

Less “angst” in “day to day” business dealings

The uncertainty is global shipping has caused much frustration, which has led to high degrees of angst.

Angst causes stress. Stress causes anger. Anger causes bad decisions. Bad decisions usually produce bad results. Eliminate angst and have more success.

Ability to work through problems and bringing quicker resolve to issues at hand

Global supply chain managers face challenges every day. Even in the best-managed supply chains, problems will occur daily. They need to be resolved quickly. Good working relationships “open the door” to quick, swift and comprehensive resolution.

Access to better security and trade compliance initiatives

Every international supply chain requires due diligence, reasonable care and supervision and control to meet various government security and trade compliance regulatory requirements.  Better working relationships foster a more secure and compliant environment to ship freight in.

Better access to and utilization of technology resources

Technology will always enhance business relationships with all the benefits of expediency, efficiency, exactness and information flow.

Technology is becoming one of the most important value-adds in business relationships in the global supply chain:

-Enhance efficiency in information flow

-Enhance correctness in information

-Allows information flow to be the conduit for more informed decision-making

-Creates KPI’s (key performance indicators) that manage accountability between the multiple parties in international transactions

-Becomes a management tool to increase overall performance, lower costs and reduce risk.

Creating a “partnership” approach

We cannot emphasize enough the importance of establishing a “mindset” between all the parties to approach matters on a “partnership” basis.  This is the best course of action that achieves “trust and confidence” between shippers, service providers, and carriers.

Trust and confidence become “hallmarks” and allows all parties to both compromise and benefit from all the actions that impact one another in the day-to-day movement of freight throughout the world.

The following key factors create a path to better relationships and sustainability.

Transparency

Share all the information necessary to get the job done right. Eliminate a “mindset” of clandestine behavior, working through “secret passageways or working in the shadows” mentality.

Put up all the data. Shippers outline clear expectations. Service providers and carriers outline clear capabilities.

A no non-sense, direct, no BS approach works best.

Valuing Favored Incumbents

Always be loyal to companies that have serviced you well. Loyalty is what you expect from your customers, so give it to your vendors and suppliers, when well deserved.

If you need to conduct an RFP (Request for Proposal) and bring in competition always give some advantage to a favored incumbent.

Be Open and Honest, Consistently

The value of being open falls in line with being transparent, but also adds on an element of “frankness, truthfulness and honesty”.  People trust those who are honest period.

When you are more honest, you can get more done as people better respect you and are more open to participate and go the extra yard to get better results.

Be Creative

The challenges of global trade can be daunting. Every approach will require a potentially different and maybe even a new revolutionary approach.

Creativity is a necessary element of being able to compete successfully, as creativity opens the door for problem resolution, progressive options, aggressive tactics and at times advanced/rebellious/extreme/mutinous behaviors.

Risk Management in assuring “Insurance” is Addressed

Claims are inevitable if you ship goods internationally. If you want to see a “relationship, go south quickly” have an unresolved claim.  Liability for loss and damage in global trade is an area of major concern.

All parties in the supply chain shipper, service provider and carrier need to know where their risk begins and ends and if there is a claim, where indemnification will originate.

When this is left unclear, it creates frustration between the parties and eventually a loss of confidence, which leads to a breakdown in any opportunity for sustainability between the parties.

Address insurance concerns proactively, comprehensively and with transparency and you will mitigate future relationship issues.

Summary

Quality relationships drive sustainability, which is always a preferred option in global trade.

The big concern is the impact all of this will have on both industrial and consumer pricing, which has and is likely to increase pricing even more than it has already with inflation raising its ugly head.

Comprehensive planning, making better more informed decisions and developing quality options and relationships create a blueprint for mitigating these supply chain challenges now and down the road.

____________________________________________________________

Thomas A. Cook is a 30 year seasoned veteran of global trade and Managing Director of Blue Tiger International, based in New York, LA and West Palm Beach, Florida.

The author of 19 books on international business, two best business sellers. Graduate of NYS Maritime Academy with an undergraduate and graduate degree in marine transportation and business management.

Tom has a worldwide presence through over 300 agents in every major city along with an array of transportation providers and solutions.

Tom works with a number of Associations providing “value add” to their membership services and enhancing their overall reach into global sourcing and in export sales management.

He can be reached at tomcook@bluetigerintl.com or 516-359-6232.

supply chain

Exclusive White Paper: Managing Inbound Supply Chains – Cost, Capacity & Delay Are The Supply Chain Manager’s “Nightmare”

The Covid-19 Pandemic which impacted global supply chains hard in February of 2020, has grown as on “steroids” as we approach the 2nd Quarter of 2021.

There is no professional logistics service provider, freight forwarder, NVOCC, Carriers, 3PL, customhouse broker, consultant, or any expert in the industry who would have anticipated what has happened in the past 12 months and likely to have a legacy well into the balance of this year.

Demand had impacted capacity and capacity has impacted cost. Ocean freight rates have doubled and in some trade lanes have tripled and air freight pricing has multiples of 4-8 times more than we witnessed towards the end of 2019.

Making this all worse is how long this crisis has developed with no specific end in sight.

Tied into capacity and cost are the logistics delays, doubling and tripling expected ETA’s.

This past year has been a “nightmare” for all supply chain managers who are looking for relief … when very little is in-sight.

The biggest influence can be observed on the Asian to North American market where the impact has been most disruptive.

In our Supply Chain Management Consulting Practice, we have been approached by hundreds of companies desperately seeking assistance in finding options and providing some relief. We will share some of our recommendations at the end of this article.

Over the 40+ years of our practice in the global supply chain, we have witnessed other times where craziness and disruptive behavior impacting freight markets. There have been at least 6 times from 1981 to 2020 where the supply chain has been disrupted in a major way.

Most professionals point to the poor management of the carriers, who have difficulty managing capacity, assets, and client’s supply chain needs when disruption is looming. While that is true to some level, there are numerous other influential areas that add to the crisis. The impact of Covid-19, greater global demand for PPE, expeditious replenishment of global inventory levels, and uncertainty in consumer and commercial spending, are but a few of the other contributing factors.

Also keep in mind, that in North America the entire domestic transportation market is also experiencing increased costs, capacity issues, and delays in providing timely, comprehensive, and cost-effective transportation services.

While we have all this “gloom and doom” in front of us, there is some light at the end of the tunnel. Here are some recommendations that we offer:

1. Recognize that in all the other times (of which we estimate that there were 6 events) of disruption in the global supply chain … in time … balance and normality eventually prevailed.

The issue in this Covid-19 Freight Dilemma … is when will we see normality? Many experts advise by April and May 2021.

Our best estimate is that while we may see some sunlight by May, supply chain executives should plan that the disruption will last till September.

Demand planning, freight purchasing, and contract negotiations would best be accomplished by anticipating freight and supply chain issues not being seriously resolved till the Fall of 2021.

2. As a supply chain executive, create a greater reach into alternative options for the acquisition of logistics services. Come out of your comfort zones, your traditional “go-to” providers, and open the doors to a larger web of players in the freight market.

3. Alternative options should include:

-Direct to Carriers

-Integrated Carriers

-3PL’s

-Freight Brokers

-Logistics Consulting Companies

-Customhouse Brokers

-NVOCC’s

-Freight Forwarders

-Freight Purchasing Groups and Associations

-Consolidators

4. Friendly competitors also can present an option where you can combine your purchasing power and leverage your freight spend.

5. Evaluating your freight spend. Consider consolidating your freight with one company by putting “all your eggs in one basket” where you may achieve getting the best value for your dollar. However, when placing all your eggs in one basket, recognize the risk associated with that option and manage that basket diligently.

6. Hire very capable staff that can bring resources, contacts, and industry relationships that might prove beneficial.

7. Work with your suppliers who also may be able to provide lower-cost or more expedient freight solutions. It is their interest as well to make sure their customers are well-served and happy.

8. Work tightly with your demand planning teams to provide timely and comprehensive information flows, so they can better plan when placing manufacturing orders. Lead times may need to be doubled and tripled. This also means working more closely and proactively with your suppliers and vendors to enhance their performance in increasing capacity and on-time capability.

9. Consider where you distribute from. Consider the demographics of where your customers are. This may conclude you adding on or expanding the warehousing locations so you can meet clients’ needs less costly and timelier. The example is if your customer base is throughout the USA and you singularly distribute from one warehouse in Baltimore Maryland, what is the cost and time element to service a customer in Chicago and one in Los Angeles?

Additionally, if the freight is sourced from China, compare the time and cost to ship from Shenzhen to Baltimore to Shenzhen to Long Beach. The warehousing and distribution costs become part of your overall competitiveness. Any steps that can be taken to help offset and mitigate the impact of higher inbound freight costs can provide various levels of some relief.

10. Be open, honest, and transparent with all the partners in the supply chain, including your customers. Extoll these virtues and they will come back to you in spades.

Working with more integrity creates camaraderie, team efforts, affords a better understanding of common concerns, and allows better partnerships to form, which ultimately produces better outcomes for all parties to an international business trade or transaction.

The Covid-19 Pandemic has turned the world of international freight upside down. It has caused a lot of frustration, headaches, loss of markets and clients, and multiple areas of serious concern for everyone involved in managing all aspects of global supply chains.

There is no question that the challenges of 2020 and the legacy now in 2021 have become ground zero for supply chain managers, but there is light at the end of the tunnel. The above outlined ten recommendations have been time-tested, battle-worn, and seasoned successful concepts in managing the risks, lowering the costs, and allowing for better-managed logistics in global supply chains.

__________________________________________________________________

Thomas A. Cook is a 30 year seasoned veteran of global trade and Managing Director of Blue Tiger International, based in New York, LA and West Palm Beach, Florida. The author of 19 books on international business, two best business sellers. Graduate of NYS Maritime Academy with an undergraduate and graduate degree in marine transportation and business management. Tom has a worldwide presence through over 300 agents in every major city along with an array of transportation providers and solutions. Tom works with a number of Associations providing “value add” to their membership services and enhancing their overall reach into global sourcing and in export sales management. He can be reach at tomcook@bluetigerintl.com or 516-359-6232.