New Articles

Guarding the Green: Exploring the Impact of Food Fraud on US Organic Farming and the French Connection

organic

Guarding the Green: Exploring the Impact of Food Fraud on US Organic Farming and the French Connection

According to estimates from the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), food fraud could affect at least 1% of the global food industry, costing as much as $40 billion. It’s a much more common issue than many may think, and it has knock-on effects on both consumers and the farming industry producing the food.

But where is the point of origin for this fraud? And how badly is it affecting the global food industry beyond the monetary loss? Electrix, a leading global supplier of electrical junction boxes that works closely with the industry, has offered expert insight into food fraud throughout the country and how it connects with other regions around the world.

A brief intro to food fraud

Food fraud is a concept that’s been around for a long time, but it cannot be stated enough how negative an impact it has on organic farming in America. Fraudulent practices in the food industry can seek to take advantage of the premium prices associated with organic products, especially as they can cost around 21% more than their conventional equivalents.

The fraudulent practices that can occur tend to be around the mislabeling of products as organic when the production of them is anything but. Similarly, actual organic products could be diluted and watered down with non-organic alternatives, or even fake organic certification could be used on the packaging.

Not only are consumers tricked into paying higher prices for products that aren’t within the guidelines required to be labeled as organic, but it can also affect their trust in organic food. This can have a huge knock-on effect on the farming sector, as legitimate organic farmers cannot face up to the fraudulent competition, which can be a massive risk to their livelihood.

The connection with France and the rest of the globe

To understand how large the issue of food fraud is, we must look at its implications around the world and how the supply chain in the industry is affected. France is an example and has a key connection with America, as many products sold on our grocery store shelves are imported and sourced from international markets like Europe.

Because of the higher prices associated with organic products and their shipments overseas, there have been scandals around fraudulent foods being misrepresented as organic, making their way from countries like France to our shores. 

The crackdown on food fraud in these countries can be seen in how those caught are being handled, such as a court in Marseille sentencing 15 people for their involvement in a network that allegedly sold meat from horses banned from the supply chain to butchers that may have been unfit for consumption. This comes as a result of traffickers of the animals falsifying documents and passports to reintroduce the animals to the supply chain.

Tackling the fraud at the source

It’s important to maintain the trust between organic farmers and both the consumers and distributors of their products, which is why cutting off food fraud at the source is crucial. How this can be done involves a multitude of approaches:

  1. Strengthening regulations:
    • Collaborative efforts internationally – Creating and maintaining relationships between nations that aim to enforce standards and consistency for organic foods is key to discovering food fraud cases before they develop into scandals.
    • Transparency in the supply chain – By implementing traceability measures throughout the supply chain, fraudulent processes and activities can be deterred. Introducing innovations like blockchain technology can provide a decentralized and tamper-resistant ledger that offers real-time information about the transportation of organic food products from farm to table.
  2. Innovating and implementing new technologies:
    • DNA testing – Technology has advanced to the point where testing the DNA is possible and can be used to identify how authentically organic a food product is. Being able to compare the genetic makeup of a product against what is expected of an organic version can help authorities identify if any fraud has occurred.
    • Smart packaging – Through implementing smart packaging solutions within the production process, consumers can access detailed information about where the product comes from, as well as certifications and testing results. This allows consumers to make informed choices about the products they’re purchasing. This can be done by attaching QR codes or RFID tags to the packaging that consumers can scan.
  3. More education for consumers:
    • Raise awareness – To improve consumer awareness of the risks posed by food fraud in organic farming, further education is necessary. This could be done through awareness campaigns to give consumers a better insight into how the products they purchase affect the industry.
    • Supporting Local Farmers – Localizing processes and production can help protect and support certified organic farmers while fostering community. Creating a direct connection between the producers and the consumers cuts out the middleman created by international supply chains and reduces the chance of fraud occurring.

Food fraud shouldn’t be disregarded, and the serious nature of its impact should be taken as seriously as other forms of fraud. Protecting organic farming throughout the country and guarding its reputation will help connect consumers with producers and establish a bond of trust and loyalty that will stimulate the economy and help develop communities.

Sources

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/15/food-fraud-secretly-infiltrates-america-heres-how-you-can-avoid-it-.html 

https://www.morningagclips.com/organic-food-sector-expects-15-growth-provoking-debate-over-price-justification/#:~:text=The%20Higher%20Cost%20of%20Organic%20Foods%20and%20Beverages&text=environmentally%20sustainable%20practices.-,In%202023%2C%20the%20organic%20food%20and%20beverage%20market%20grew%20by,breast%20is%20%2410.99%20per%20pound

https://www.foodsafetynews.com/2023/01/sentences-handed-out-in-french-horse-meat-trial/ 

 

organic farming

U.S. States With the Most Organic Farms

As the force that feeds and nourishes the population, agriculture is one of the most vital industries in the U.S. economy. To accommodate the country’s growth over the years, agricultural practices have evolved to become more efficient, capable of reliably meeting the population’s daily needs. But these efficient practices also come with environmental costs, and many farmers and consumers are increasingly seeking out more sustainable alternatives.

Organic farming is an approach to agriculture that attempts to mimic nature and natural processes when raising crops and livestock. Rather than using techniques of larger-scale industrial agriculture, like genetic modifications, monoculture farming, and synthetic fertilizers and pesticides, organic farmers seek to conserve biodiversity and natural resources on their farmland.

Organic products have seen a boom in demand in recent years, and there are a number of reasons why consumers might be seeking out organic products. Organic techniques appeal to environmentalist consumers who value a more sustainable approach to agriculture that promotes biodiversity, limits pollution, and increases carbon capture. For meat and dairy consumers, livestock production on organic farms is considered to be a more ethical and humane way to raise animals because they are given more access to the outdoors, better feed, and fewer hormones and antibiotics. Health-conscious consumers can point to evidence that organic products have health benefits like greater nutrient density and lower levels of toxic metals and pesticide residue than conventional agricultural products.

Whatever the reasons, organic farming has increased substantially over the last decade or so. In 2008, the U.S. had 10,903 organic farms covering around 4 million acres of farmland. In 2019, there were nearly 16,500 organic farms on 5.5 million acres. And these farms have grown alongside consumer demand: the sales of organic products have more than tripled over the same span, rising from $3.1 billion to $9.9 billion.

Within the nearly $10 billion organic food market, milk, chicken, and eggs are the top-selling products. Organic milk leads all products with sales of more than $1.5 billion per year, while chicken sees $1.1 billion in sales annually and eggs generate $887 million. Apples are the top-selling form of organic produce, with $475 million in annual sales.

While the organic farming industry has seen tremendous growth, not all farmers are adopting organic practices. Many large-scale agricultural operations in the Midwest and South have relatively low numbers of organic farms and acreage devoted to such operations. But one location where organic agriculture has taken hold deeply is California. California is home to more than 3,000 organic farms—more than twice the next-highest state—and the total acreage of organic farms in the state totals nearly 1 million acres.

California is the nation’s top state for agricultural sales overall, so it is unsurprising that the state is also the leader in organic production. In relative terms, several other states devote a greater share of their farmland to organic farming than California, where organic farms represent only about 4% of the state’s agricultural acreage. Instead, the list of top states for organic farms on a relative basis is led by northeastern states including Maine, New York, and Vermont—the runaway leader, where organic acreage accounts for nearly 17% of its total.

The data used in this analysis is from the USDA. To identify the states with the most organic farms, researchers at Commodity.com calculated the total certified organic acres operated as a percentage of total farmland in each state. In the event of a tie, the state with the greater number of organic farms as a percentage of total farms was ranked higher. Only states with available data from the USDA were included in the analysis.

Here are the states with the most organic farms.

State Rank Organic acreage as a percentage of total Organic farms as a percentage of total Total organic acreage Total organic farms Total value of organic products sold
Vermont    1   16.92% 9.63% 203,002 655 $159,742,000
New York    2   4.68% 3.96% 323,081 1,321 $298,420,000
Maine    3   4.25% 6.00% 55,261 456 $63,820,000
California    4   3.97% 4.31% 965,257 3,012 $3,596,923,000
New Hampshire    5   2.72% 1.95% 11,708 80 $11,274,000
Wisconsin    6   1.75% 2.10% 250,940 1,364 $268,921,000
Massachusetts    7   1.63% 1.85% 8,170 133 $32,895,000
Nevada    8   1.60% 1.19% 97,868 40 $66,803,000
Idaho    9   1.57% 0.98% 180,732 240 $205,968,000
Pennsylvania    10   1.47% 1.79% 107,550 944 $741,764,000
Michigan    11   1.25% 1.15% 122,253 541 $230,955,000
Oregon    12   1.24% 1.22% 196,045 455 $454,406,000
Utah    13   0.88% 0.27% 94,591 48 $26,903,000
Maryland    14   0.86% 0.97% 17,196 120 $50,080,000
Ohio    15   0.82% 1.01% 111,920 785 $116,999,000
United States    –   0.61% 0.81% 5,495,274 16,476 $9,925,911,000

For more information, a detailed methodology, and complete results, you can find the original report on Commodity.com’s website: https://commodity.com/blog/most-organic-farms/