New Articles

EIN vs. VAT: Understanding the Differences for International Businesses

global trade VAT EIN

EIN vs. VAT: Understanding the Differences for International Businesses

Navigating taxes for international businesses can be a complex landscape, especially when you’re required to work with identifiers from multiple countries. Two essential tax identifiers that frequently come up in global business discussions are the Employer Identification Number (EIN) and the Value-Added Tax (VAT) number. Although both are important, they serve different purposes and operate under distinct jurisdictions. 

This article will break down what EIN and VAT are, why businesses might need them, and how each is used in cross-border transactions.

What is an EIN?

An Employer Identification Number (EIN) is a nine-digit number issued by the U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to identify businesses for tax purposes. Often compared to a Social Security Number but for businesses, the EIN is essential for tax reporting, payroll management, opening business bank accounts, and establishing business credit in the U.S..

Who Needs an EIN?

In the U.S., businesses that hire employees, operate as corporations or partnerships, or file certain tax returns are required to have an EIN. Foreign businesses with U.S.-based operations, such as those selling goods or services within the United States, may also need an EIN, especially if they’re required to file U.S. tax returns. 

Having an EIN helps foreign businesses to interact seamlessly with the U.S. market, allowing them to open bank accounts, apply for certain licenses, and enter into contracts with U.S. clients​.

Why You Might Need an EIN Lookup Tool

If your business has misplaced or forgotten its EIN, using an EIN lookup tool can help retrieve it quickly. EIN Lookup services like EINsearch, provide an easy solution to find EINs without needing to contact the IRS, which saves time and prevents interruptions in operations. Businesses looking to ensure compliance can rely on this tool as a quick resource to keep their documentation in order.

What is VAT?

VAT, or Value-Added Tax, is a consumption tax levied on goods and services at each stage of the supply chain. Unlike the EIN, which is specific to the U.S., VAT is implemented in more than 160 countries worldwide, including all European Union countries. For international businesses, VAT comes into play when selling goods or services to customers within these regions.

VAT is often seen as an indirect tax because it is ultimately borne by the end consumer, while businesses in the production chain generally reclaim the VAT they’ve paid. However, the need to collect, track, and remit VAT accurately can significantly impact a business’s pricing, sales strategy, and compliance practices.

Who Needs a VAT Number?

Businesses selling goods or services in countries with VAT requirements generally must register for a VAT number. For example, a U.S.-based eCommerce business that sells products to customers in the European Union may need to register for VAT in each country where they exceed certain sales thresholds. These thresholds vary by country, and VAT rates also differ, adding complexity to the process​.

VAT and Cross-Border Transactions

In cross-border transactions, VAT regulations require businesses to collect VAT based on the customer’s location. This impacts international eCommerce companies especially, as they need to charge and remit VAT for digital and physical products sold across various regions. For companies not registered for VAT in a customer’s country, non-compliance can lead to penalties, potential bans, or customer dissatisfaction due to unexpected import fees.

Key Differences Between EIN and VAT

1. Purpose and Jurisdiction

  • EIN: The EIN is strictly a U.S.-based identifier for federal tax purposes. It is required for U.S.-related activities, such as filing federal taxes, managing payroll, opening business bank accounts, and applying for U.S.-specific licenses.
  • VAT: VAT numbers are international identifiers required in any country that has a VAT system, which includes most of Europe, parts of Asia, and other regions. They’re essential for businesses conducting sales within these countries, as VAT laws often apply based on the customer’s location.

2. Business Application

  • EIN: Mainly used for U.S. tax-related activities, including payroll and federal tax filing. It’s also important for businesses looking to establish credit, hire employees, or create a legal business structure in the U.S.
  • VAT: Primarily for tracking tax obligations on goods and services sold in VAT-implementing regions. VAT is applied at each stage of production and distribution, requiring companies to track sales and submit returns for each market.

3. Scope of Taxation

  • EIN: Impacts U.S. income reporting, payroll, and certain excise taxes. It is not directly related to sales tax, although it can be tied to specific tax filings required by the IRS.
  • VAT: VAT influences the pricing of products across different regions, as it’s levied on the final sale to consumers. It also affects how taxes are collected and remitted based on where a business sells its goods or services​.

4. Registration Process

  • EIN: Issued by the IRS without charge. Both U.S.-based and certain foreign businesses can apply if they meet IRS requirements.
  • VAT: VAT registration can be complex, involving country-specific rules and varying sales thresholds. Businesses need to be aware of each country’s VAT obligations and the documentation required.

Why Some International Businesses Might Need Both an EIN and VAT Number

Expanding to new markets often means meeting multiple tax requirements. Global businesses operating in or selling to both the U.S. and VAT-based countries may need both an EIN and a VAT number. For example, a foreign eCommerce company with significant U.S. sales might need an EIN for U.S. federal tax purposes, while its European operations require VAT registration.

Common Scenarios Requiring Both an EIN and VAT Number

  1. eCommerce Across Borders
    A non-U.S. company selling to both American and European customers would need an EIN for tax compliance in the U.S. and VAT registration for the EU, especially when surpassing specific sales thresholds.
  2. Physical Expansion into Multiple Countries
    If a Canadian company sets up a physical office or distribution center in the U.S., an EIN would be necessary. Meanwhile, sales to EU customers would necessitate VAT registration to comply with regional tax regulations.
  3. Digital Services and SaaS Companies
    For software and digital services sold internationally, VAT registration is often required, especially in the EU. However, for U.S.-based sales, an EIN may also be necessary, making both identifiers essential.

Day-to-Day Operations and Compliance with EIN and VAT Numbers

Having both an EIN and a VAT number helps businesses streamline their compliance processes. An EIN aids U.S. businesses in managing payroll, opening accounts, and filing federal taxes efficiently. VAT registration allows international businesses to handle complex tax requirements across different countries, ensuring they can track sales, calculate taxes, and provide clear pricing to customers in different markets.

Final Thoughts

Understanding the differences between EIN and VAT is essential for any business looking to expand globally. Each identifier plays a unique role in facilitating compliance with local tax laws, enabling businesses to navigate multiple tax regimes effectively. 

For companies planning international growth, knowing when and why to use EIN and VAT numbers can help them remain compliant, avoid penalties, and build a reliable foundation for their global operations. Proper management of these identifiers will not only aid compliance but also foster trust among customers, suppliers, and regulatory bodies in each region.

 

competition

Intimidated By The Competition? How Your Startup Can Take On The Big Guys.

When newly formed businesses size up the competition, they may not like what they see.

Often, major players in their industry are already well ahead of them, drawing in the customers or clients they covet, cornering the market on the best employees, and pushing around through their sheer size anyone who dares take them on.

But startups don’t necessarily have to blink in the face of the big guys, says Adam Witty, himself a successful entrepreneur and the ForbesBooks co-author of Authority Marketing: Your Blueprint to Build Thought Leadership That Grows Business, Attracts Opportunity, and Makes Competition Irrelevant.

“Certainly, major corporations have plenty of advantages over startups, from the assets they have available to the years of brand recognition they have worked to achieve,” says Witty, who also is the founder and CEO of Advantage|ForbesBooks (www.advantagefamily.com). “But you can work on creating a few advantages of your own – or at least create a more level playing field – if you approach things in the right way.”

He says some ways for budding entrepreneurs to do that include:

Know that adaptability is a key asset – and possibly an advantage. The COVID-19 pandemic brought a lot of attention to the importance of being able to adapt, but it’s always been critical for businesses to respond to unanticipated changes in the market that threatened their product or business model, Witty says. “Being adaptable doesn’t mean just introducing a new product to your realm of offerings,” he says. “It requires constant attention to what’s going on in the world, analyzing your competitors, and most importantly, not getting too comfortable at the top of the pyramid.” In some cases, a startup can even have an advantage here, Witty says. Established businesses sometimes get stuck in their ways, and when disruptions happen in the economy or with customer habits, they are slow to make the necessary changes. A good example of this was Blockbuster, the video rental company that failed to see the threat that annoying upstarts like Netflix posed.

Turn customers and clients into raving fans. The most profitable companies in the world boast the most fanatical clients and customers, Witty says. “Think about Apple, which does many things very, very well,” he says. “One of them is servicing the customer first. And Apple excels in communicating its mission to its audience. Zappos CEO Tony Hsieh once said, ‘Customer service shouldn’t just be a department. It should be the entire company.’ To create loyalty, you must show customers that you not only are grateful for their business but that you value their relationship.”

Establish yourself as the authority in your field. Positioning yourself as the go-to person in your field allows you to create an unfair advantage in the marketplace by immediately positioning you above others in the same field, Witty says. One way to do that is by writing a book because then you are not only an authority on your topic but you “wrote the book on it.” But you can also begin to establish your authority through media interviews and speaking engagements, Witty says.

Finally, Witty says he’s fond of telling his employees, “When it comes to decision making, if we’re going to go with opinions, we’ll go with mine.”

In reality, he doesn’t want to make decisions based on even his opinion; he prefers facts and data.

“For a startup or any business to be successful,” Witty says, “you should let employees know that you are open to their ideas, but you also expect those ideas to be backed up with facts and data that demonstrate why it’s a good idea. That kind of decision making is the best way for your business to grow, prosper and dominate the competition.”

____________________________________________________________

Adam Witty, co-author with Rusty Shelton of Authority Marketing: Your Blueprint to Build Thought Leadership That Grows Business, Attracts Opportunity, and Makes Competition Irrelevant, is the CEO of Advantage|ForbesBooks (www.advantagefamily.com). Witty started Advantage in 2005 in a spare bedroom of his home. The company helps busy professionals become the authority in their field through publishing and marketing. In 2016, Advantage launched a partnership with Forbes to create ForbesBooks, a business book publisher for top business leaders. Witty is the author of seven books, and is also a sought-after speaker, teacher and consultant on marketing and business growth techniques for entrepreneurs and authors. He has been featured in The Wall Street Journal, Investors Business Daily and USA Today, and has appeared on ABC and Fox.

united states secretary PPE

Doing Business in the United States: Challenges and Experiences of European Companies

European companies open branches in the United States for a host of reasons. For starters, the United States gives these businesses a completely new base of customers; a chance to step out from the almost saturated European market and stand out from the crowd. Secondly, there are many government incentives in the U.S., making the business environment incredibly favorable. Last but not least, it gives them more brand recognition and a chance to reinvent their products in a hungry, welcoming market. 

Starting a business or moving an existing business from Europe to the U.S. can, indeed, be an exciting time for an entrepreneur. However, that is not to mean that aren’t any thorny experiences and business-threatening challenges to contend with while there. Nevertheless, before commencing your business transition to the USA, you must be sure to acquire the necessary visa, so that you do not do anything illegally which might cause problems later on. 

Apart from the UK-based businesses, those coming from other parts of Europe may have to hire a translation company to translate their content for localization purposes. That would mean higher initial and overall running costs. Besides that, here are some of the other challenges and experiences that European companies encounter when doing business in the United States:

Strong multicultural influence

The U.S. is a country founded on the pillar of unity in diversity; there are too many ethnic groupings in the country, each with their own unique culture and needs, yet they all expect outsiders to see them as one inseparable people. The multiculturalism in this country is on another level; you will have to contend with it in government offices and in the business setup. 

How you handle the employees is also affected by this cultural influence as there are some historical injustices that plague the labor market up to today. That is not particularly the case in Europe as most countries in the region have a homogenous culture. Your success or failure might be tied on this seemingly inconsequential factor.

Complexity in the taxing system

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS)- revenue service of the United States federal government- is very strict with its enforcement of the federal taxes, sometimes to the point of scaring off investors who come from jurisdictions with lenient tax laws. And as if that is not enough, you will also have to deal with tax collection authorities both at the state and local levels. 

Even though the government is in the process of lowering the transition tax to about 8-15% and the corporate tax from 35% to 21%, there still are some vital teething issues that would demand a skeptical approach to America’s taxation framework.

The financial sector’s influence

Wall Street, arguably the most influential financial sector in the world, is keener on short-term profits and high stock values and not the traditional long-term value opportunities. The hedge funds and investment firms on Wall Street have become so powerful that without their blessings, you may be forced to sacrifice your brand’s reputation just to impress them.

High competition from multinational corporations

America is home to some of the biggest multinational corporations. While you will greatly benefit from their existence in terms of benchmarking on their success, sometimes the competition they bring forth can be unbeatable. To make matters worse, these corporations have political connections and friends in the highest places in the demand and supply chain, so they often get the lion’s share of government incentives.

Most multinationals have their planning and thinking inclined to global markets which, apparently, greatly affect the nation’s job market. They will hire the best talents in the country and proceed to outsource and offshore manufacturing jobs to other countries overseas. That means that they will enjoy both the benefits of hiring cheap outsourced labor and highly-qualified American professionals. Also, competing with a country that outsources cheap manufacturing services can be a daunting task. 

Complicated electricity and construction rules

If you wish to acquire property in the U.S., probably your main offices, you will have to pass through more than 10 bureaucratic steps before you get the legal permits to register it under your company name. Environmental inspections and reviews, for example, can take weeks if not months. In big cities such as Los Angeles and New York, you may have to wait for more than 2 months to have your electricity turned on. And if you need additional constructions in the property, that can cost you anywhere between 3,000 to 6,000 USD $ in terms of building plan check and permit.

______________________________________________________________

George Foster is a marketing manager at Day Translations.