New Articles

HOW DUBAI CUSTOMS STOPS COUNTERFEIT PRODUCTS FROM ENTERING THE SUPPLY CHAIN

counterfeit

HOW DUBAI CUSTOMS STOPS COUNTERFEIT PRODUCTS FROM ENTERING THE SUPPLY CHAIN

Dubai Customs continues to position itself as a leader in countering illicit product transport, with regular reports showcasing the efforts and successes throughout each year. Dubai Customs remains one of the leading organizations in halting counterfeit imports in the supply chain. Additionally, the organization continues to lead efforts in sustainable solutions for discarding seized products. In 2020, the organization recycled 1,906 counterfeit items ranging from computers to athletic shoes and mobile headphones.

In this exclusive Q&A with His Excellency (HE) Ahmed Mahboob Musabih, director general of Dubai Customs, we get a behind-the-scenes peek at how the organization continues protecting consumers and the environment from counterfeit products and the international supply chain from illicit trade.

Global Trade (GT): Please discuss how Dubai Customs has successfully stopped counterfeit products from entering the supply chain.

HE Musabih: Dubai Customs works to perform all UAE obligations under international trade regulations and agreements and pays great attention to the protection of intellectual property [IP] rights. These efforts have led the United States to a decision to remove the UAE from the Watch List for Intellectual Property, according to the annual report of the Office of the United States Trade Representative [USTR], an affiliate of the U.S. federal government, on the Intellectual Property Protection. 

The total number of IP disputes resolved by the department in the first quarter of 2021 was around 81 disputes, with an estimated value of AED [Emirati dirham] 11.3 million. In 2020, 255 IP disputes were resolved, with an estimated value of AED 62.2 million.

One of the most prominent seizures carried out by the department was the foiling of the smuggling of 58 counterfeit goods of oil and gas pipes based on a complaint received by the department from [Middle Eastern IP consultancy] Cedar White Bradley regarding counterfeit goods loaded in four containers coming from an Asian country to Dubai. The goods were to be brought to the UAE as original goods of oil transport pipes bearing the Vallourec trademark. These pipes posed significant risks to the environment as they were not capable of withstanding high pressure that the original pipes of that trademark were designed to withstand. This could have caused serious environmental damage if the counterfeit pipes reached the country of origin and were used for oil and gas projects.

Our efforts to combat counterfeit goods have resulted in the application of a series of measures and steps adopted by the department to resolve IP disputes relating to trademark counterfeiting goods. These measures and three steps are as follows:

1. Customs inspectors in our customs checkpoints suspect counterfeit goods through inspection activities.

2. Counterfeit goods are pre-monitored by the Smart Risk Engine System developed by the department to identify risks in commercial shipments prior to their arrival to our customs checkpoints.

3. A trademark infringement complaint is filed by the trademark owner or its legal representative.

GT: What role does technology play in halting counterfeit trade? 

HE Musabih: Advanced electronic systems and applications effectively contribute to countering attempts to smuggle counterfeit goods through pre-monitoring of risks in commercial shipments. Dubai Customs has developed the Smart Risk Engine System to manage and analyze customs risks efficiently to determine risk levels in future shipments and track prohibited, restricted goods and counterfeit goods before they reach customs posts of Dubai. This process is completed by inspection and detection by highly skilled customs inspectors. 

Last year, the department organized 10 workshops that were attended by 309 participants to familiarize customs inspectors and officials with how to distinguish between counterfeit and original goods. In the first quarter of 2021, two workshops were organized, which were attended by 68 participants.

The technology used in risk management has enabled us to control counterfeit goods. For example, the Customs Intelligence Department and Air Customs checkpoints management inspectors worked in coordination with the IPR Department to successfully thwart an attempt to bring a shipment bearing the “Vaseline” counterfeit trademark in the quantity of 17,280 packages coming from an Asian country via air freight, with a market value of about AED 400,000. 

GT: What are some best practices Dubai Customs recommends for preventing counterfeit/illicit trade?

HE Musabih: Prevention of illicit trade of counterfeit goods is an integrated process that should include thwarting the smuggling of goods across borders through cooperation between customs departments, border control and partnerships with the private sector represented by trademark owners. This requires development of the technologies used in inspection activities and improvement of the performance of customs inspectors through continuous training while raising awareness among consumers of the dangers of counterfeit goods.

The IPR Department, through the Awareness and Education Division, contributes to raising awareness about the importance of implementing the IPR Policy internally and externally, so that internal awareness activities target customs officials and inspectors while external awareness events organized by the department target all groups of society. The number of awareness events organized by the department in the first quarter of 2021 to inform customers, partners and the public of the importance of protecting intellectual property rights, reached 12 awareness events. There were 1,394 beneficiaries of these events, including inspectors, government department staff and school students. In 2020, about 46 awareness events were organized with 2,358 beneficiaries from these categories.

The department applies environmental sustainability standards in combating counterfeit goods to achieve the UAE Agenda for Sustainable Development by stopping shipments containing counterfeit goods while avoiding environmental damage resulting from their destruction, through recycling of counterfeit goods. Through these operations, Dubai Customs prohibits the re-export of counterfeit goods to limit the trade of these goods in the world. The department has recycled about 510, 000 pieces of counterfeit goods of 26 trademarks during the first quarter of 2021. In 2020, about 161,800 counterfeit goods of 60 trademarks were recycled.

GT: How does Dubai Customs ensure the security of the supply chain?

HE Musabih: Dubai Customs is making its best efforts to prevent counterfeit goods, having allocated substantial budget to develop its system of procedures through smart devices and innovations launched by the department with a view to improving its ability to counter smuggling attempts, most notably high-capacity scanners [X-ray]. Goods within containers are detected with six scanners operating under the Advanced Container Scanning System in Jebel Ali, with a capacity of scanning 900 containers per hour. These are supported by the operating room, which follows up on operations in customs checkpoints in addition to the Early Trademark Information System and the Smart Risk Engine System targeting risk shipments.

We have an intelligence-led approach to preventing illicit trade, which relies on effective data collection and analysis, risk profiling and targeting. The comprehensive system uses technology to support public awareness, detection, enforcement and sector-specific intelligence around illicit trade and smuggling activities that pose risk for the economy and the society. But when it comes to tackling illicit trade in counterfeits, we believe that improved IP enforcement and regulatory compliance are key, but this alone will not be enough without engaging all stakeholders and consumers through enhanced consumer protection and public awareness initiatives to ensure demand for counterfeit products is reduced. 

Learn more: 

https://www.dubaicustoms.gov.ae

https://www.wfmj.com/story/42253899/counterfeit-vallourec-tubes-seized-in-dubai

https://gulfnews.com/uae/crime/dubai-customs-foil-bid-to-smuggle-fake-vaseline-worth-dh400000-1.79303481

UAE

Intellectual Protection Efforts from United Arab Emirates (UAE) cause United States to lift UAE from Watch List of Intellectual Protection (IP)

United Arab Emirates (UAE) reaches a new milestone in Intellectual Protection (IP) from the United States Trade Representative (UTSR) decision to remove UAE from the watch list for IP protection and enforcement. In the UTSR annual report, it was reported that the UAE applied adequate and effective measures to protect and enforce intellectual property rights as per IP related international standards and global best practices. The annual report highlights the compliance and increased efforts of UAE that lead to the removal of the watchlist after longstanding IP concerns.

The UTSR stated in the report on global IP compliance that the UAE made progress on longstanding IP enforcement lead by federal authorities and local governments pushing a series of IP enforcements on longstanding IP enforcement standards. The decision holder H.E. Sultan Ahmed Bin Sulayem, CEO and Chairman of DP World Group and Chairman of Ports, Customs and Free Zone Corporation (PCFC), welcomed the decision of the taking the UAE off the watchlist and underlined the UAE for the commitment in implementing IP regulations.

H.E. Sultan Ahmed Bin Sulayem stated, “We are pleased that Dubai Customs’ IP efforts have contributed to this achievement by the UAE. This underpins strategic plans to increase foreign trade growth, in fulfillment of the wise leadership’s directives and particularly the trade roadmap vision approved by His Highness Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Vice President and Prime Minister of the UAE and Ruler of Dubai, which sets out a five-year plan to boost Dubai’s foreign trade to Dh2 trillion,” as he boosted over UAE performance.

Efforts by Dubai UAE POV:

H.E. Sultan Ahmed Bin Sulayem explained that Dubai Customs has been actively engaged in tackling the illicit trade of counterfeits, while being in full corporation with the US and other foreign bodies. The Dubai Customs works in tandem with the IPR departs to enforces intellectual property and trademark laws by making sure that any IPR infringing goods are seized to prevent from entering local markets.

H.E. Ahmed Mahboob Musabih, Director General of Dubai Customs said, “Dubai Customs has long been steadfastly committed to intellectual property rights protection. In 2005, we established the IPR department, the first of its kind at the level of customs authorities in the Middle East, with the aim of optimizing coordination amongst different customs units and centers in the area of enforcement and protection of intellectual property rights,” when describing Dubai Customs efforts in protecting IPR laws.

In 2021, Dubai Customs organized twelve workshops to introduce training of distinguishing between counterfeit products targeted at 1,394 staff and students. This training led to Dubai Customs resolved 81 intellectual property disputes, with an estimated value of Dh 11.3 million and recycled 510,000 counterfeit items for 26 international brands.

The Director of the IPR department, Yousuf Ozair Mubarak, mentioned that Dubai Customs teams constantly communicate with US and foreign countries to understand their needs and requirements in respect of protection and enforcement of the IP rights to ensure business interests of their partnering organizations.

Code obfuscation

Code Obfuscation: What it is and should You Use It?

Certain programming languages like .NET and Java can very easily be decompiled to readable sources. There are a lot of definitions about code obfuscation, but to explain it better the code obfuscation is the process that makes your application binaries slightly harder to read with a decompiler. It is a very important tool to protect the intellectual property of your business.

Why Obfuscate Code?

Some compiled languages get converted directly to bytecode, for example, C++. If you want to reverse engineer, the only way to work is with a disassembler, which is a complicated and arduous process. Though, it is not impossible, inferring high-level app logic from a stream of assembly language is quite difficult.

On the other side, languages like Java and C# are not compiled for any particular OS. They are more complied to an intermediary language, such as MSIL from .NET’s. This intermediary language is very similar to assembly, but it’s very easily converted back into the source code. So this does mean that in case you have an executable or public Dynamic-link library (DLL), anyone who possesses a copy of your executable are able to open it up in, let’s say dotPeek (.NET decompiler), and directly read your source code, and copy it as well.

Any .NET DLL can be plugged into a decompiler, so code obfuscation cannot prevent this process. But what obfuscation does is use a number of things in order to make the source code very annoying to read and debug.

Renaming is the simplest form of this entity. It is a very common practice to properly name all of the methods, variables, parameters and classes according to what function they do. But of course, you don’t have to do that, so there is nothing that is really stopping you from naming them with lowercase L’s and I, or random similar combinations of unicode characters, just to make the code very hard to read and debug. For the computer, it is all the same, but to a human is very difficult to distinguish.

It could look something like this:

IlIIIIlIIIllIIIllIIll

lIIIllIIllIlIIIIlIIIl

(neat, right?)

This process will be handled automatically by a basic obfuscator, taking the output from the build and then converting it to something that is really, really hard to read. By doing this there is no performance decrease to non-obfuscated code.

There are types of advanced obfuscators that can make it possible to change the structure of the source code. This means it can replace control structures with identical syntax but it looks more complicated.

It can also embed a code that doesn’t do anything, but it would make it harder to read for the decompiler. This means the source would look like ‘spaghetti code’ – which means it would annoy anyone who tries to read the code.

Hiding strings – is one of the common things. In this way, string obfuscation can replace strings with encoded messages – which are also decrypted, and it makes it difficult to search for them from a decompiler.

There are lots of options for obfuscators, it depends on the language the obfuscators are using. For example, Obfuscar, ProGuard, Javascript-obfuscator. etc.

Another option: You can convert to a Compiled Language

Actually, you can convert one programming language to another one, isn’t that a hard or crazy idea. It is an effective way to secure games from cracking, and it is an important step to do when protecting from piracy and cheaters. For example, Unity uses an IL2CPP converter to transform .NET code into C++ bytecode.

Is it necessary to Obfuscate?

Untrusted environments exist – so if you are using a code, and you want to secure it, it is important to use an obfuscator to make decompiling hard.

Securing your code is a must. Using an obfuscator is a must. If you don’t want anybody to decompile your app, you should try switching to a language that doesn’t have these problems.

expand

How to Effectively Expand Your Business Globally

These days, businesses that are quickly growing don’t necessarily know the ‘do’s and don’ts’ of expanding into new jurisdictions.  In this post, we will dive into the key issues you should project manage as you plan your expansion beyond borders.

Elon Musk, Jack Ma, Steve Jobs. Each of them started small but shared an outsized goal of making the world a different place. Eventually, they all accomplished this, becoming some of the most influential entrepreneurs the world has ever seen, and scaling their businesses globally.

Almost every business owner I’ve met has similar-sized ambitions. Few are content with staying small. They want to build something that can make a massive impact and become a household name.

But the gulf between aspirations and reality is often vast. You may be standing in your way by not doing something important from the beginning: thinking globally.

Location. Location. Location.

When your company is looking to expand business overseas, pay attention to where and why. Especially the “why.” For instance, many American companies are setting up in various portions of Europe because of the critical talent in those areas. Once you’ve decided on the best location for your business to grow, it’s then time to hire. In your country of choice, you may need to hire a country manager that can help build a team as well as a person or many who can run that facility in areas including administrative, R&D, sales, etc.

Next, you have a few different ways you can expand into your chosen country. The smallest footprint you can have is a rep office, one being established to run market research, but governments have strict limits on how long you can have a rep office. For example, in Singapore, you can only set one up for one-year, but you can get a two-year extension. So, know exactly what you plan to accomplish.  Setting up a subsidiary will be the right choice if you want to send a message that you are there to stay.

If you establish a local subsidiary or other local legal entity, you may need to establish a minimum capital reserve, make your entity subject to legal liability in that jurisdiction, pay taxes, comply with corporate formalities around incorporation, shareholder and board meetings (how frequently and where they are held), local directors and shareholders (nationalities) and more, maintain a local corporate secretarial function, make public disclosures of your accounts, maintain a bank account and comply with local commercial rules that impact how you record revenues and bookings.

While sometimes your business is simple enough that compliance can be managed by an outsourced service or local law firm, some jurisdictions will require you to have people on the ground.

People in places

As you start your operations, next, you’ll have human capital considerations. When you hire somebody overseas, you need to follow local laws. For instance, in Poland, the contract must be bilingual if you are a foreign employer. Bilingual requirements exist in many countries, including Canada, France, Germany, Russia, Ukraine, and Japan. However, in other countries like Singapore and Australia, you will not need to worry about this.

Additionally, you may have to find a payroll service, but there are limitations in some countries, including China, Serbia, and Russia, to get capital into and out of the country. So, it might be necessary to open up a local bank account to pay your local employees. In some countries, you are even able to wire the money to the employees and the government.

How you pay your people may have currency requirements.

Whether you are bringing in human capital locally or from the home country, you may need to complete pre-hire checks and comply with immigration regulations.

Employment regimes

In certain countries like Poland, employment is a matter of the contract, not at-will, which is different in a country like the U.S. The U.S. is the only country that offers employment-at-will. You can say, “I do not want you to work here anymore.” And then you can leave at that moment. But, in most countries, you have to give notice by contract and get severance.

Most countries have collective bargaining agreements, which sometimes can benefit you, while other times not. For instance, if you are party to a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) in Sweden, it negates the need to deal with each employee as a bargaining unit, negotiate with the union or the CBA, and all the employees fall under it. Depending on the country, you have to comply with local working time regulations – for instance, you can’t work on weekends in France. And, in California, if you work more than eight hours a day or 40 hours a week, you’ll receive overtime pay.

When it comes to expanding your business, the right hiring process is just as necessary as the proper exit process. This protects you from being sued for employment practices. By executing the correct standard, the right contract, and the country’s law, you ensure no breach of your contract for the employee or the employer. Next, you have to think about benefits because even though you have an infrastructure that supports medical care in many socialist countries, most employees are used to having supplemental benefits.

Intellectual property protection

This also relates to intellectual property if you hire contractors to do your development work in a foreign country. The IP they are creating may belong to their contractor and not to the company paying for it, so it’s key to have agreements in place with the contractor, so you own your IP.

If you are conducting R&D or exploiting patents or trademarks created in the home country, local intellectual property regimes will be essential in protecting the IP that you create, export, import and ultimately monetize. Sometimes, that might also mean the capability to enforce your IP rights in a country.

Compliance requirements

Beyond employment law, there are compliance requirements to pay close attention to. For example, you may need to have a registered office or provide an office address to the local government. The office might need to be staffed during business hours if somebody wants to give notice, or the government wants to get in contact with your business. In some countries, like Spain, this is changing to an electronic system where you must have a registered email that the government can use to send communications.

When it comes to data privacy, there seem to be new and overlapping (if not contradictory) national, regional, and local regulations published every day. In Europe, the General Data Privacy Regulation, or GDPR, has strict requirements that apply to companies far beyond the borders of the European Union. The China Data Protection Directive has civil and criminal repercussions to those accessing Chinese consumers through the Internet and otherwise. Recently, the California Consumer Privacy Act, or CCPA, became subject to enforcement.  Going global means threading the needle to ensure that you have compliant solutions everywhere you are doing business.

Taxes

Depending on your footprint, it could create a “permanent establishment,” which makes some portion of your revenues subject to tax in a particular jurisdiction. If you establish a permanent establishment, you will have to file a tax return at the end of the year. Even if you do not have a permanent establishment, you may need to file another type of tax return and comply with other requirements.

Additionally, there are tax requirements from both an indirect perspective and a direct perspective. For instance, if you are making a lot of money, you might have requirements to pay estimated taxes during the year and file the income tax return at the end of the year.

Summing it up

Technology, life sciences, medical device, and clean energy companies can not be successful when confined to one or more jurisdictions. Indeed, by definition, they know no borders. To disrupt markets and build share, new businesses increasingly need to grow faster, and go global, from the earliest stages of development. Accessing global markets is key to achieving value and liquidity, and ultimately, ubiquity. Good advisors are critical to helping companies define and execute on a mission to expand their business globally.

______________________________________________________________

Louis Lehot is the founder of L2 Counsel, P.C., an elite boutique law firm based in Silicon Valley designed to serve entrepreneurs, innovative companies and investors with sound legal strategies and solutions.  Mr. Lehot is a corporate, securities and M&A lawyer, and he helps his clients, whether they be public or private companies, financial sponsors, venture capitalists, investors or investment banks, in forming, financing, governing, buying and selling companies. He is formerly the co-managing partner of DLA Piper’s Silicon Valley office and co-chair of its leading venture capital and emerging growth company team. 

Kateryna Mamyko-Golomb is a law clerk with L2 Counsel, P.C. She advises corporate clients, startups, and investors. She graduated Cum Laude from Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law. Previously, Kate clerked with a major global law firm in Silicon Valley, and prior to her LLM, Kate led an independent corporate law practice in Central and Eastern Europe and served as General Counsel for one of the leading startup accelerators in the region. Kate graduated Summa Cum Laude from Taras Shevchenko National University where she published her thesis: “Government Regulation of Technology Venture Investment” and clerked for the Kyiv District Attorney.

L2 Counsel, P.C. is an elite boutique law firm based in Silicon Valley designed to serve entrepreneurs, innovative companies and investors with sound legal strategies and solutions.

Anti-Counterfeit Efforts Finally Go Global

Washington, DC – It’s no longer just the US and the European Union that are concerned with the festering issue of counterfeit products, say Michael Czinkota and Ilkka Ronkainen of Georgetown University.

“Globally, companies reportedly lose a total of $657 billion every year because of product counterfeiting and other infringement on intellectual property,” they say. “Today’s key problems are with high-visibility and strong brand name consumer goods.”

Intellectual property enforcement “ensures that new ideas can blossom into economic opportunity,” they’ve written in a recently published paper addressing the topic of counterfeit goods.

“Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) have become a core issue in the global economic debate. No longer confined to cheap knockoffs of luxury goods, IP theft is placing industry and the public at risk of highly adverse economic, safety, and health consequences,” they added.

Earlier, the only concern was whether a company’s product was being counterfeited; now, the raw materials and components purchased for production may be counterfeited.  In general, countries with lower per capita incomes, higher levels of corruption in government, and lower levels of involvement in international trade tend to have more intellectual property violations.

Ronkainen teaches marketing and international business at Georgetown University, while Czinkota researches international business and policy issues at the school.

According to the writers, China, long seen as the focal production point of global counterfeiting operations, has taken significant steps to counter what has plagued the country’s e-commerce market particularly hard.

Alibaba “spends more than $16 million yearly fighting counterfeit goods,” they say. Another example is “Hong Kong’s commitment to the protection” of intellectual property.

“With the goal of enhancing consumer confidence in Hong Kong, and to strengthen the city’s reputation as a ‘Shopping Paradise’ for genuine products, the Intellectual Property Department has launched the ‘No Fakes Pledge’ scheme,” Czinkota and Ronkainen said.

The issuing bodies of the scheme are the Hong Kong & Kowloon Electrical Appliances Merchants’ Association Limited and the Hong Kong Coalition for Intellectual Property Rights of the Federation of Hong Kong Industries.

“The international marketer must act to enforce intellectual property rights.  No industry or country is immune from infringement, nor can they address the threat alone. There is also need for better education regarding the risks IPR violations pose and how to defend against them,” they said.

For example, the pharmaceutical industry lobbied to make sure that provisions for patent protection in the NAFTA agreement were meticulously spelled out.

Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers (PhRMA) addressed the issue of international IP protection by responding to the Special 301 Report issued by the US Trade Representative in May 2012.

The PhRMA statement cited the need for IP protections in spurring innovation, research and development, as well as the need for fair international market conditions to ensure that patients have access to medications.

One research firm estimated the global market for counterfeit pharmaceuticals to generate revenues between $75 billion and $200 billion a year.

The Pharmaceutical Security Institute (PSI), a trade association created to address illegal pharmaceutical incidents, collects data on the number of counterfeiting, illegal diversion, and theft incidents. These incidents increased seventy-eight percent from 2005 to 2009.

Pfizer reports that between 2004 and 2010 it seized more than 62 million doses of counterfeit medicines worldwide.  More than 200 million counterfeit Eli Lilly medicines have been seized in 800 raids around the world.

“A number of other governments are drafting similar policies, which have served as a catalyst for enhancing protection in both the public and private sectors in those nations,” said Czinkota and Ronkainen.

Efforts to protect intellectual property, and modernize the patent and trademark system are crucial, they added.

“The power of creativity and innovation applied to the solving of practical problems is not the exclusive province of any country or people. A victory over fakes and counterfeits will protect the quality and reliability of products and services, and lets customers be more informed and secure in their usage decisions.”

10/21/2014

WTO Slams China for Lack of Trade Transparency

Los Angeles, CA – China is coming under harsh criticism from the World Trade Organization with members of the 160-nation body asserting that Beijing has failed to live up to key transparency commitments it made when it joined the organization in 2001.

The WTO Secretariat recently released the results of a critical 200-page report on China’s trade policy which concluded that, over the past two years, the country continues to exhibit a lack of clarity, organization and centralization of its trade rules and regulations.

EU ambassador Angelos Pangratis described the lack of clarity on trade issues as “striking,” while Canada’s representative also criticized the “often vague and insufficent information available” from Beijing.

Release of the report came during the WTO’s recent, bi-annual policy review held at the group’s headquarters in Geneva, Switzerland.

Many of the 50 WTO members who took part in the review also criticized Beijing’s use of export restraints and taxes, restrictions on foreign investments and said it must improve protection for intellectual property rights (IPR).

The US Representative to the WTO, Christopher Wilson, said that China’s “apparently retaliatory conduct” in its use of duties, and said the country appeared to ignore a number of WTO findings against it.”

Wilson added, “An enormous amount of work remains if China is to close significant loopholes in its legal framework and reduce the unacceptably high IPR infringement levels.”

Responding to the WTO report, China’s Assistant Minister of Commerce, Wang Shouwen said its findings were “baseless” and that China “has one of the best track records of implementing WTO rulings.”

But, he added, though China “has made great strides to address these issues…it has pledged to do more to improve transparency.”

07/30/2014